5.25% No-Minimum Savings Account (New York CU)
May 16, 2006 - 12:48 PM by Ken Tumin
If Citibank's 4.75% no-minimum savings account sounds good, how about 5.25%? The yield on RateEdge.com's no-minimum online savings account reached 5.25% APY today. RateEdge.com has consistently maintained a yield higher than the online savings accounts offered by the banks. Unfortunately, RateEdge.com is a division of Sunmark FCU which has a field of membership (FOM) that's primarily limited to those who live in areas of New York State.
One note regarding their FOM, you can also be eligible even if you don't live in this area of New York State. If an immediate family member lives, works, worships, owns a business, volunteers or attends school in this area, you are eligible. Your family member doesn't have to already be a RateEdge member.
As you can see below, RateEdge has consistently maintained a high yield on their savings account. Since I began tracking them in November, they've maintained an APY 25 basis points above the intended federal funds rate. RateEdge has also had the lead over EmigrantDirect and HSBC except during HSBC's 4.80% promotion (for most of the promotion RateEdge was only behind by 0.05%).
RateEdge doesn't exactly have a no-minimum savings account since it requires a balance of $5. For practical purposes, I consider this as a no-minimum account. According to their FAQ, the savings account seems to have a nice ACH transfer system that allows you to link not only to checking accounts but also money market accounts and brokerage accounts. There are some fees that you should be aware of such as a fee when you go over 2 outbound ACH transfers.
As I mentioned in last month's post when RateEdge reached 5%, I wish more credit unions would follow the lead of Sunmark FCU and set up an online division to focus on high-yield online savings accounts. Brick-and-mortar credit unions have consistently offered better rates than B&M banks. As RateEdge has shown, this can also be true with online divisions. I've emailed my credit unions about RateEdge and asked them to consider setting up a similar division. More credit unions will likely offer this if more people request it.
One note regarding their FOM, you can also be eligible even if you don't live in this area of New York State. If an immediate family member lives, works, worships, owns a business, volunteers or attends school in this area, you are eligible. Your family member doesn't have to already be a RateEdge member.
As you can see below, RateEdge has consistently maintained a high yield on their savings account. Since I began tracking them in November, they've maintained an APY 25 basis points above the intended federal funds rate. RateEdge has also had the lead over EmigrantDirect and HSBC except during HSBC's 4.80% promotion (for most of the promotion RateEdge was only behind by 0.05%).
RateEdge RateEdge Fed Funds Emigrant HSBC
Rate Change APY Rate Direct APY APY
May 16 5.25% 5.00% 4.50% 4.50%
Apr 05 5.00% 4.75% 4.50% 4.80%
Feb 09 4.75% 4.50% 4.25% 4.80%
Jan 07 4.50% 4.25% 4.00% 4.25%
Nov 14 4.25% 4.00% 4.00% 4.00%
RateEdge doesn't exactly have a no-minimum savings account since it requires a balance of $5. For practical purposes, I consider this as a no-minimum account. According to their FAQ, the savings account seems to have a nice ACH transfer system that allows you to link not only to checking accounts but also money market accounts and brokerage accounts. There are some fees that you should be aware of such as a fee when you go over 2 outbound ACH transfers.
As I mentioned in last month's post when RateEdge reached 5%, I wish more credit unions would follow the lead of Sunmark FCU and set up an online division to focus on high-yield online savings accounts. Brick-and-mortar credit unions have consistently offered better rates than B&M banks. As RateEdge has shown, this can also be true with online divisions. I've emailed my credit unions about RateEdge and asked them to consider setting up a similar division. More credit unions will likely offer this if more people request it.


Sidd (anonymous) - #1, Tuesday, May 16, 2006 - 5:14 PM
Learned something today that is interesting:
FDIC insurance on IRAs increased to $250K per account on April 1st.
Can eliminate managing multiple accounts..
mark (anonymous) - #2, Wednesday, May 17, 2006 - 5:02 PM
Until a few weeks ago, I thought I'd never make money off the fact that my wife's family lives in Albany, NY. RateEdge has changed that.
HSBC account owners will find the "bank transfer" interface very familiar. Unfortunately, so is the sluggish (3-5 days) ACH transfer process, but that's about the only complaint I have
Banking Guy (anonymous) - #3, Wednesday, May 17, 2006 - 6:40 PM
sidd, unfortunately, the limit didn't apply to non-IRA accounts. But these will go up starting in 2011 based on inflation. Refer to this post for more info.
Mark, thanks for your inputs on RateEdge. I guess the delays are probably more tolerable when the rates are so high.
Add Your Comment
Post a Comment