Bank Deals Weekly Summary for May 16, 2009

May 16, 2009 - 6:34 PM by Ken Tumin

Hot Deals, Quick Link for Rates, Recap of this week's posts

An important question for savers is how fast will the economy recover? As the economy improves, inflation will rise which will lead to higher interest rates. The tough question is how fast and how severe will inflation be? With the Fed printing money and with the federal government's massive spending programs and deficits, there are worries about high inflation around the corner. Based on this, savers may want to avoid locking their money into long-term CDs. However, high inflation in the next year is no sure thing. This Naked Capitalism post describes other complexities in this issue and makes a case that deflationary forces will likely continue to dominate for some time into the future. So you may not want to place all of your bets on higher interest rates in the next year.

Savings Account Rates

As we've seen over the last 6 months, this interest rate environment is very depressing for savers as savings account rates keep falling week after week. What can help reduce this frustration are savings accounts which provide a rate-guarantee period. I posted on a new bank this week with such an offer. EBSB Direct is guaranteeing 2.81% APY for balances over $50K until 9/30/09 on new savings accounts (see review). Another savings account promo that I posted on in late April is still available at ProvidentNJ Direct. They're offering a 3.25% APY guaranteed for 90 days (see review). Another one of these promos is being offered by Acacia Federal Savings Bank. When I first posted on it in late March they were offering a modest 2.25% APY guaranteed until 9/30/09. I just noticed on their home page it's now listed as 2.50% APY. However, if you click on the image with the 2.50%, it takes you to a promo page that's still showing 2.25%. So I'll have to call Monday to find out which is correct. Update 5/18/09: I called this morning and was told the 2.25% APY is the correct rate.

Other banks have done similar intro-rate promos this year, and they haven't lasted long. The latest example is at Choice Financial which had been guaranteeing 3.76% for 30 days along with a standard rate of 3.26% APY for balances over $100K. On Tuesday the rates were cut by a full percentage point on both the promo and standard rates. Another example was at Clear Sky Accounts which launched its savings account in early January with a 3.75% APY guaranteed through 3/31/09. In February the bank stopped accepting new applications and even limited new deposits by existing customers. So in today's rate environment, don't expect these promos to last long.

Installment Savings Accounts

If you want rates over 4% there is another alternative besides reward checking accounts. It's called an installment savings account. However, the effective interest rate that you earn will likely be much less than what's advertised. I've reported on several local-only installment savings accounts in the last couple of months. One that is available nationwide is at Wilshire State Bank (see review). The rates range from 4.60% APY for a 12-month term to 5.12% APY for a 36-month term.

The important thing to remember for installment savings accounts is that you don't make a lump sum deposit. Deposits are spread across the term with equal deposits made each month. Before the auto deposits are made into the installments savings accounts, money will have to be in the bank's checking account which will earn little if any interest. With the help of an online bank that has an ACH transfer service, you could arrange for most of the money to be sitting in a high yield savings account before it's transferred to the checking and then into the installment account. If you assume a 2% APY in the online savings account for the entire year and the 4.60% APY 12-month installment savings account, your one-year return for a lump sum initially deposited into the savings account will be close to 3.40%. However, if you deposited the lump sum into the bank's checking account which earns little if any interest, your one-year return will be around 2.47%.

Below is the list of savings account rate changes for this week. The one big disappointment was the large rate cut at the new Choice Financial. On the plus side, Corus Bank raised its money market account rate by 2 basis points (a tiny increase is better than nothing).

Rate Hikes:
  1. EBSBdirect Savings - 2.81% $50K+ thru 9/30/09 (new)
  2. Bank of American Fork Savings - 2.20% $1K+ (new)
  3. Corus Bank MMA - 2.20% (was 2.18%)
Rate Drops:
  1. Bank Provident Online - 1.90% (was 2.00%)
  2. Imperial Capital iMMA - 1.17% to 1.86% (was 1.35% to 2.03%)
  3. Imperial Capital iChk - 0.91% (was 1.20%)
  4. Mutual Bank MMA - 2.01% (was a 2.21% 3mo promo)
  5. Zions Bank MMA - 2.02% (was 2.10%)
  6. OneUnited - 1.75% (was 2.00%)
  7. HSBC Direct Savings - 1.55% (was 1.65%)
  8. Intervest MMA - 1.90% (was 1.95%)
  9. Choice Financial Savings - 1.76% to 2.26% (was 2.76% to 3.26%)
  10. Citibank USA - 1.50% (was 1.65%)
  11. ADB Bank MMA - 2.10% (was 2.25%)
Certificate of Deposit Rates

The big news for CDs this week was at GMAC Bank which changed its name to Ally Bank (see post). The one significant change was the addition of the no-penalty CD. It has a 9-month term with a very competitive rate of 2.50% APY. With this CD, you can protect yourself from falling rates over the next 9 months. If rates do rise over this time or if you just need the money, you can close the CD early without an early withdrawal penalty. The only downside is if rates are still low after 9 months. In that case you would have been better off earning a higher rate in a longer term CD.

Unfortunately, there are not many options of earning higher rates for longer terms. Pentagon Federal Credit Union continues to be one of the better deals with its competitive rates for terms of 3, 4, 5 and 7 years.

Some of the CD deals I reported on in previous weeks (like at PenFed) continue. Below are some of the best new and old ones that are still active.

Best Nationwide CD Deals as of 5/16/09: The full list of nationwide CD rates is farther down.
  1. 3.25% 3-mo savings account promo at ProvidentNJ Direct (account review)
  2. 2.81% savings promo thru 9/30/09 at EBSB Direct (account review)
  3. 2.50% 4-mo CD at Danvers Bank (account review)
  4. 2.52% 6-mo CD at Wilshire State Bank (account review)
  5. 2.50% 9-mo No-Penalty CD & 2.80% 12-mo CD at Ally/GMAC Bank (account review)
  6. 3.03% 12-mo CD at Melrose CU (account review)
  7. 3.50% 36-mo CD & 4.00% 60-mo CD at Pentagon FCU (account review)
Best Local CD Deals as of 5/16/09: Some of the best CD deals are from banks and credit unions that don't offer accounts nationwide. Refer to the recap section and the state index section to find all the recent local deals. Here are some of the best deals to note.
  1. 3.29% 6-mo CD & 3.87% 15-mo CD at Progressive CU in NY, NY (account review)
  2. 2.89% 7-mo CD & 3.05% MMA at Raymond Bank in WA (account review)
  3. 2.75% 6-mo CD ($25K max) at STC Capital Bank in Chicago (account review)
  4. 3.00% 9-mo CD at Pacific Transportation FCU in CA (account review)
  5. 3.25% 12-mo CD at Cornerstone Bank in GA (account review
  6. 3.00% 12-mo CD at First Priority CU in MA (account review)
  7. 3.30% 12-mo CD at Self Reliance New York FCU (account review)
  8. 3.10% 25-mo CD & 2.65% 6-mo CD at CoreFirst Bank at CO & KS (account review)
  9. 3.00% 25-mo CD at Broadway Bank in Chicago (account review)
  10. 4.50% 60-mo CD & 2.75% 12-mo CD at Urban Trust Bank in FL & MD (account review)
Reward Checking Accounts

I reported on three new reward checking accounts this week with rates ranging from 4.01% to 5.01% APY (see below). BancVue, the creator of the reward checking account, has helped several institutions launch reward checking accounts branded as Kasasa Cash accounts. The name change doesn't mean much to me, but of more significance is the new Kasasa Saver account. This is designed to be a companion account with the Cash account that may appeal to those with liquid savings over the balance caps of the Cash accounts. You can move money that's over the cap in the Cash account to the Saver account. If you meet the typical reward checking requirements, the Saver account will receive a respectable interest rate for all balances without any small balance cap. The Saver interest rate isn't at the reward checking level, but it's comparable to online savings account rates. So this Kasasa Cash/Saver pair can be a good option for those with large balances and who just want to stick with one bank. Unfortunately, there are not many banks and credit unions offering this pair. The only one offering it nationwide is First Arkansas Bank & Trust which does have a history of competitive rates (see post).

One bit of disturbing news in regards to reward checking accounts happened this week at Arizona Bank & Trust. Many readers reported receiving a letter from the bank informing them that they are closing all out-of-state accounts as of July 1st. It appears this bank may have been overwhelmed by their 6% promo they offered early last year. In the past when small banks attracted too many customers, they just stop accepting out-of-state applications, and that's what Arizona Bank & Trust did last year. But now they're taking it to another level by closing these accounts. I have not seen other banks take such extreme measures, and I hope this doesn't start a trend. Unfortunately, it appears banks may close deposit accounts for any reason (per OCC).

To see all of the high yield reward checking accounts available through out the nation, please refer to my High Yield Checking website.

Recap for the Week - Links to This Week's Posts

Banking News

Savings/Checking Accounts - National

CD Deals - National

Credit Card Deals

Reward Checking Accounts

CD and Money Market Deals - Local

The rates listed below are based on Annual Percentage Yield (APY). No minimum balances are required unless noted. MMA next to the rates indicate a money market account. Most MMAs have check writing and ATM cards. Online savings accounts usually lack both of these. The top lists include banks and credit unions with broad availability and with minimums around $10K or less. Previous weekly summaries are available at this page. Quick Links: Refer to the following links for the savings accounts and CDs that interest you: Liquid Account Rates: Savings Accounts, Reward Checking, Bank alternatives CD Rates: 3 Mo CDs, 6 Mo CDs, 9 Mo CDs, 12 Mo CDs, 18 Mo CDs, 24 Mo CDs, 36 Mo CDs, 48 Mo CDs, 60 Mo CDs, 84 Mo CDs, CDs by state Comments: read and discuss

As of May 16, 2009

Checking/Savings/Money Market Accounts:


3-Month Certificates of Deposit:

6-Month Certificates of Deposit:

9-Month Certificates of Deposit:

12-Month Certificates of Deposit:

18-Month Certificates of Deposit:


24-Month Certificates of Deposit:

36-Month Certificate of Deposit:

48-Month Certificate of Deposit:

60-Month Certificate of Deposit:

84-Month Certificate of Deposit:

Various Deposit Account Deals


High Yield Reward Checking Accounts - Open to All


Recent CD Specials at Local Credit Unions and Banks


Bank Account Alternatives


Historical Rates from the Federal Reserve (Federal funds, Treasury bills, CD's)

In order of date posted. - Sort by votes
Anonymous

Anonymous - #1, Saturday, May 16, 2009 - 10:05 PM

A great summary this week. Thanks for all your hard work banking guy!


1
AG

AG (anonymous) - #2, Sunday, May 17, 2009 - 11:23 AM

Hey there, really a great work. Keep it up!


1
Anonymous

Anonymous - #3, Friday, May 22, 2009 - 3:34 PM

Despite the abominably low rates we're receiving on our deposit accounts, the yield on the 30-year US Treasury Bond today rose to its highest level in almost eight months. The drop in bond prices has been attributed to supply and credit concerns, but could a fear of inflation be fueling it as well? Gold and oil prices are rising, and commodity inflation can precede inflation on the wholesale and retail levels.


1
Anonymous

Anonymous - #4, Friday, May 22, 2009 - 6:13 PM

Special assessment on banks approved by FDIC:
http://www.fdic.gov/news/news/press/2009/pr09074.html

No rest for the weary: Following yesterday's closure of BankUnited, FSB, we already have one additional closure today: Strategic Capital Bank in Champaign, IL.


1
Anonymous

Anonymous - #5, Friday, May 22, 2009 - 6:55 PM

Number two for today: Citizens National Bank in Macomb, IL.


1

Add Your Comment


Post a Comment