Dedicated to Deposits: Deals, Data, and Discussion

Reward Checking Updates - New Nationwide Account & Application Issues

POSTED ON BY

I just added a new reward checking account to my list of nationwide accounts. It's offered by Community National Bank and it's paying 4.51% APY on balances up to $25K as of 7/05/09. I first posted on it last month. I just learned that it's available nationwide at CheckingFinder.com. For more details of this account, refer to my account review.

As we've learned this year, small banks that offer competitive reward checking accounts nationwide often don't continue this for too long. The latest example of this is at First Arkansas Bank & Trust. It has been offering 4.44% APY on balances up to $50K since February 2008 (see review). It had been available nationwide, but recently they've started excluding California residents. I'm not sure why they chose California, but I wouldn't be surprised if they add other states.

This California restriction complicates my reward checking tables. I currently can't handle almost-nationwide accounts. I still have it in my nationwide list, but I've added a note of this restriction at the top of the account review.

Rejected Due to ChexSystems Inquiries

Being rejected due to your location isn't the only reason for being rejected these days. More people are being rejected for having too many recent ChexSystems inquiries. When you apply for an account at many banks, they will do a ChexSystems inquiry to ensure that you haven't abused accounts at other banks (such as unpaid fees). However, many not only look for abuses, but they also look at the number of recent ChexSystems inquiries (MyMoneyBlog has a good review of ChexSystems and how you can get your report for free.)

I was told by a FABaT customer service rep that they will reject applicants with more than 4 ChexSystems inquires in the last 6 months.

With banks slashing rates, people are being forced to find new banks if they want to earn a decent rate of return. So this use of ChexSystems is especially tough on savers these days.

Reward Checking Account References:


Related Posts

Comments
8 Comments.
Comment #1 by Anonymous posted on
Anonymous
I've learned that chexSystems gives you a score, but they won't tell you what it is. However, if a bank rejected you based on that score, the bank might tell you your score if you ask politely.

1
Comment #2 by Anonymous posted on
Anonymous
Just read one of your other postings re these accounts (the one about the math behind these accounts) I just opened an account at a local bank and when I questioned the csr about how many people fail to meet the monthly requirements he said 70% failed to do so. I was surprised it was so high. I think most of their costumers are local as I don't see this bank listed in your list or others' list of these accounts and only learned about it in local newspaper ads. I don't think they are ready for prime time yet as he also told me some ways they have erred with this account since its recent inception.reogish

1
Comment #3 by Anonymous posted on
Anonymous
Re ChexSystems, I hadn't applied for or opened any great number of new bank accounts lately.

But two months ago, because I had a maturing CD that I wasn't going to renew at low rates, I applied for a 4.5% rewards checking account at Farmers & Merchants Bank, and to my surprise, was denied on the basis of CS, according to the bank.

The next day, I applied online for the 4.44% First Arkansas Bank and Trust rewards checking account, and was immediately accepted.

So the lesson is, I think sometimes, the banks just use the CS results as an excuse...for doing whatever they want to do for their own internal reasons.

1
Comment #4 by Bob (anonymous) posted on
Bob
The percentage of Reward checking account holders who fail to meet the monthly requirements needs to be taken with a grain of salt.

For instance, I have a few reward checking accounts where I fail to meet the requirements month after month. My balance in those accounts: $5.00 each.

1
Comment #5 by Data Is Gold (anonymous) posted on
Data Is Gold
I was rejected from opening an Alliant CU checking account because of the chex system. I immediately filled out the request for ChexSystem report to see what was happening. Much to my surprise, Alliant sent my a welcome packet and my debit card before I even received my CS report.

When I did get my CS report, there wasn't any negative information. Go figure.

1
Comment #6 by Anonymous posted on
Anonymous
Bob is spot on. What would be more meaningful would be the avg. daily balance of a/c not qualifying for Reward as a percentage of the average daily balance of all Reward a/c.

1
Comment #7 by Rick (anonymous) posted on
Rick
"...recently they've started excluding California residents."

My guess is that the bank doesn't want California residents trying to deposit IOUs in their checking accounts. It is just easier to just not let them open an account to begin with.

1
Comment #8 by Anonymous posted on
Anonymous
Have a Michigan zipcode and just got rejected by First Arkansas Bank and Trust because of my location.

1