Bank Deals Weekly Summary for September 5, 2009

Sep 5, 2009 - 6:29 PM by Ken Tumin

Hot Deals, Quick Link for Rates, Recap of this week's posts

Five small banks failed on Friday which brings the total bank failures in 2009 to 89. Four of the five failures were the typical type in which the FDIC was able to find buyers to assume all deposits, even those above the FDIC limit. For these cases, the only concern for depositors will be the possibility of having rates cut on existing CDs.

The closure of one of the five banks, Platinum Community Bank in Illinois, won't go so smoothly for depositors. In this case the FDIC wasn't able to find a buyer, and consequently, the FDIC is mailing checks for the insured deposits. Those with over the FDIC limit will likely lose their uninsured deposits. In addition, all accounts were closed, so those with checking accounts will no longer be able to use the accounts to pay bills or withdraw money at ATMs.

Out of the 89 bank failures this year, I've counted 8 that have been closed without the FDIC being able to find a buyer. In 2 out of these 8 closures, the FDIC established a temporary bank that remained opened for 30 days after the closure. This gave customers with checking accounts some time to transition over to a checking account at another bank. For the other 6 closures (including the one yesterday), the FDIC didn't establish a temporary bank, and it closed all accounts immediately. This is the worst case scenario, and fortunately, it has been rare this year.

Savings Account Rates

EverBank reduced its 3-month intro rate from 3.01% to 2.51%. So there are now no more 3% savings account rates on my nationwide list.

The best non-promo rate continues to be the savings account at Tennessee Commerce Bank which has a 2.30% APY for balances up to $100K. The rate drops to 1.50% APY for over $100K. Another downside to this account is a $2.50 withdrawal fee when there is more than one withdrawal per month (see post). This rate has held since I posted on this in June. Perhaps the above negatives are preventing a flood of deposits.

In my opinion, the best savings account when you consider both rates and account features is from Alliant Credit Union. Its rate is 2% APY, and this is scheduled to hold through September. It also has a long history of competitive rates. The account features are not the best, but they're respectable. Alliant Credit Union is also much more financially healthy than many of the banks offering top rates (see post).

One big disappointment this week was at United Central Bank which cut 50 basis points on all rate tiers of its Global Money Market Account. This takes it far away from the top of the savings account list (account review).

Another disappointment was ETrade Bank's rate cut of its Complete Savings Account. When ETrade Bank cut the rate to 0.95% APY in early May I had thought surely it wouldn't go any lower. I was wrong. A couple of months ago it fell to 0.80%, and this week it fell to 0.60%. When an online bank is offering a savings account rate less than half the rate of ING Direct's Orange Savings Account, the rate is definitely too low.

Below is the list of rate changes for this week.

Rate Hikes:
  1. None
Rate Drops:
  1. EverBank 3mo promo MMA/Chk - 2.51% (was 3.01%)
  2. Delta Community CU MMA - 1.85% $25K-$50K (was 2.00%)
  3. United Central Bank Global MMA - 1.65% $75K+ (was 2.15%)
  4. Bank of American Fork SaveSmart Direct - 1.60% (was 1.75%)
  5. EverBank MMA stnd rate - 1.51% (was 1.75%)
  6. Danvers Bank online savings - 1.50% (was 1.65%)
  7. Corus Bank MMA - 1.49% (was 1.65%)
  8. Bank Provident Online Savings - 1.45% (was 1.55%)
  9. Capital One/Costco MMA - 1.40% (was 1.50%)
  10. Capital One MMA - 1.20% (was 1.30%)
  11. ETrade Bank Complete Savings - 0.60% (was 0.80%)

Certificate of Deposit Rates

One new short-term CD deal that I just noticed today as I was updating the rates is at H&R Block Bank which is offering a special 2.00% APY 6-month CD. I'll post more on this next week. In the mean time, refer to my old post on the H&R Block Bank and its CD features.

Many of the banks and credit unions that were offering top CDs cut rates this week. There were a few bright spots. One was at Mountain America Credit Union which raised its 60-month CD rate from 3.25% to 3.40% APY. The nice thing about MACU's long-term CDs is that the early withdrawal penalty is only 90 days of interest [ Update 9/07/09: See see comment below ]. With a 90-day interest penalty for a 3.40% CD, a withdrawal after one year results in a one-year APY of 2.55% (0.75x3.40) which is much better than any 1-year CD rate nationally available. I'll post more on this next week. In the mean time, refer to my old post on MACU and its CD features.

Below are some of the best nationwide and local CD deals that are still active.

Best Nationwide CD Deals as of 9/05/09: Also listed are savings account promos with rate guarantee periods. The full list of nationwide CD rates is farther down.
  1. 2.51% 3-mo money market/checking promo at EverBank (account review)
  2. 2.05% 3-mo savings account promo at 1st Constitution Direct (account review)
  3. 2.00% 6-mo CD at H&R Block Bank (account review)
  4. 2.10% 10-mo CD at OneWest Bank (account review)
  5. 2.36% 15-mo CD $175K min, 2.05% $1K min at USAA Bank (account review)
  6. 2.27% 12-mo CD at Melrose CU (account review)
  7. 2.25% 16-mo CD at DollarSavingsDirect (account review)
  8. 2.25% 18-mo CD at NASA FCU (account review)
  9. 2.78% 25-mo CD at Crane FCU (account review)
  10. 3.50% 55-mo CD at NASA FCU (account review)
  11. 4.00% 60-mo CD at Citibank in-branch in some states (account review)
  12. 3.91% 60-mo CD at Melrose CU (account review)
  13. 3.80% 60-mo CD at Apple FCU (account review)
  14. 3.50% 60-mo CD at iGObanking (account review)
  15. 3.40% 60-mo CD at Mountain America CU (account review)
Best Local CD Deals as of 9/05/09: Some of the best CD deals are from banks and credit unions that don't offer accounts nationwide. Refer to the recap section and the state index section to find all the recent local deals. Here are some of the best deals to note.
  1. 5.00% 6-mo CD ($25K max) at Tyndall CU in Panhandle FL (account review)
  2. 2.50% 7-mo CD & 2.60% 11-mo CD at Fort Knox FCU in KY (account review)
  3. 2.25% 6-mo CD ($25K max) at STC Capital Bank in Chicago (account review)
  4. 2.25% 7-mo CD at Pan American Bank in Chicago (account review)
  5. 2.59% 10-mo CD at Altana FCU in MT (account review)
  6. 3.00% 15-mo CD at Bartow County Bank in GA (account review)
  7. 3.00% 12-mo & 3.25% 24-mo CD at Jefferson Financial CU in Louisiana (account review)
  8. 2.58% 12-mo CD at Fort Bragg FCU in NC (account review)
  9. 2.50% 12-mo CD at Valley National Bank at Some NYC branches (account review)
  10. 2.50% 12-mo CD at Eastman CU in Several States (account review)
  11. 2.40% 15-mo CD & 2% 6-mo CD at Southern Commerce Bank in FL (account review)
  12. 2.60% 18-mo CD at Settlers Bank in WI (account review)
  13. 2.27% 12-mo CD at American Plus Bank in Southern CA (account review)
  14. 2.65% 18-mo CD & 2.40% 11-mo CD at Island FCU in NY (account review)
  15. 3.25% 27-mo CD & 2.50% 15-mo CD at Enterprise Bank of SC (account review)
  16. 4.00% 36-mo Liquid CD & 2.75% 18-mo CD at Darby Direct in GA (account review)
  17. 3.25% 42-mo CD at Regions Bank in Several States (account review)
  18. 4.15% 60-mo CD at Neighborhood CU in TX (account review)
  19. 4.07% 60-mo CD at United Community CU in IL & MO (account review)
  20. 4.00% 60-mo CD at PFFCU in Philadelphia (account review)
  21. 4.00% 60-mo CD at Citibank branches in CA, NV & FL (account review)
Reward Checking Accounts

I reported on five new reward checking accounts this week with rates from 4.01% APY to 5.25% APY. Unfortunately, all are local deals. However, I posted on two reward checking accounts that I've recently confirmed are available nationwide. One is Incommons Bank in Texas which is offering 5.01% APY on balances up to $25K. The other is Commonwealth Bank & Trust Company which is offering 4.50% APY on balances up to $25K. This 4.50% APY is guaranteed to last until May 2010 (see post).

To see all of the high yield reward checking accounts available throughout the nation, please refer to my High Yield Checking website. Note, I'm in the process of updating rates.

Recap for the Week - Links to This Week's Posts

Banking News

CD Deals - National

Checking/Savings Bonuses

Reward Checking Accounts

CD and Money Market Deals - Local

The rates listed below are based on Annual Percentage Yield (APY). No minimum balances are required unless noted. MMA next to the rates indicate a money market account. Most MMAs have check writing and ATM cards. Online savings accounts usually lack both of these. The top lists include banks and credit unions with broad availability and with minimums around $10K or less. Previous weekly summaries are available at this page. Quick Links: Refer to the following links for the savings accounts and CDs that interest you: Liquid Account Rates: Savings Accounts, Reward Checking, Bank alternatives CD Rates: 3 Mo CDs, 6 Mo CDs, 9 Mo CDs, 12 Mo CDs, 18 Mo CDs, 24 Mo CDs, 36 Mo CDs, 48 Mo CDs, 60 Mo CDs, 84 Mo CDs, CDs by state Comments: read and discuss

As of September 5, 2009

Checking/Savings/Money Market Accounts:


3-Month Certificates of Deposit:

6-Month Certificates of Deposit:

9-Month Certificates of Deposit:

12-Month Certificates of Deposit:

18-Month Certificates of Deposit:


24-Month Certificates of Deposit:

36-Month Certificate of Deposit:

48-Month Certificate of Deposit:

60-Month Certificate of Deposit:

84-Month Certificate of Deposit:

Various Deposit Account Deals


High Yield Reward Checking Accounts - Open to All


Recent CD Specials at Local Credit Unions and Banks


Bank Account Alternatives


Historical Rates from the Federal Reserve (Federal funds, Treasury bills, CD's)

In order of date posted. - Sort by votes
Anonymous

Anonymous - #1, Sunday, September 6, 2009 - 6:50 PM

For NH resident only:
St. Mary's Bank
3 year special step-up CD
year 1 3.00% APY
year 2 3.50% APY
year 3 4.00% APY
Blended rate 3.56 APY


1
Anonymous

Anonymous - #2, Monday, September 7, 2009 - 11:36 AM

Regarding Mountain America CU MACU.com, I found the following in their membership agreement: "Withdrawal of the principal amount of your term deposit may be made only with the consent of the Credit Union. [...] Owners of accounts with a stated term of more than one year
shall forfeit an amount equal to 90 days dividends on the amount
withdrawn, or the length of the term, whichever is less, when any withdrawal is allowed."

I wonder if this may put the early withdrawal plan after 1 year for a 5 year CD into jeapordy.

P.S. Long time reader, first time poster - great blog! Thank you so much!


1
Banking Guy

Banking Guy (anonymous) - #3, Monday, September 7, 2009 - 11:51 AM

Thanks for the info. That's a good point about requiring the consent of the CU for the early withdrawal. I've updated the post with a link to your comment. I discussed this general issue in this previous post.


1

Add Your Comment


Post a Comment