Bank Deals Weekly Summary for January 31, 2010

Jan 31, 2010 - 11:30 AM by Ken Tumin

Hot Deals, Quick Link for Rates, Recap of this week's posts

There was another FOMC meeting last week, and as expected, the Fed continues to say they intend to keep the federal funds rate exceptionally low for an extended period. However, there was one voice of dissent at the FOMC. Thomas Hoenig, a new voting member this year, voted against this. Hoenig "believed that economic and financial conditions had changed sufficiently that the expectation of exceptionally low levels of the federal funds rate for an extended period was no longer warranted." With Bernanke's confirmation for another term, I wouldn't expect much change this year at the Federal Reserve. If the economy strengthens, perhaps we'll see a change of policy later this year. If there's any new economic weakness, it might be a long wait for us savers.

Savings Account Rates

Like the previous week, there were not a lot of banks cutting their savings account rates. Hopefully, we are at or near a bottom of this interest rate cycle.

There were a few disappointments this week. 1st Constitution Direct and Wilshire State Bank cut their savings account rates from 1.50% to 1.25% APY.

SmartyPig continues to pay 2.01% APY on their special savings account. One bit of interesting news came from the bank that holds SmartyPig deposits, WestBank. In their fourth quarter results, they announced their plans to transition SmartyPig deposits to a larger bank. This is due to SmartyPig attracting too many deposits (see post).

As one reader commented, let's hope a too-big-to-fail bank does not become SmartyPig's bank. Rates are set by the bank, not by SmartyPig, so it's important that the new bank will be committed to keeping SmartyPig's interest rates high. Another reader mentioned a potentially positive outcome from this transition. WestBank also offers a high-yield reward checking account. The reader speculated that WestBank may be more likely to keep their reward checking rates high since they won't have all of those SmartyPig deposits.

Rate Hikes:

  1. None

Rate Cuts:

  1. Countyank Reward Checking - 4.01% (was 4.75%)
  2. Coulee Bank Reward Checking - 3.33% (was 4.04%)
  3. 1st Constitution Direct Savings stnd rate - 1.25% $10K (was 1.50%)
  4. Wilshire State Bank eLink Savings - 1.25% (was 1.50%)
  5. TotalBank e-Savings - 0.85% (was 1.00%)

Certificate of Deposit Rates

Short-term CD rates continued to fall this week. It's getting harder and harder each week to find 12-month CD rates of 2% or higher. Franklin Synergy Bank cut is internet 12-month CD rate from 2.10% to 2.00% APY. Jacksonville Bank cut its 12-month CD rate from 2% to 1.75% APY.

With the new month starting on Monday, many credit unions, such as Pentagon Federal Credit Union, may be cutting their CD rates. So make sure you check their websites for the latest rates.

iGObanking's 3.55% 5-year CD

On the positive side, there were some rate hikes on long-term CDs. The biggest increase was at iGObanking.com (internet division of Flushing Savings Bank) which raised its 60-month CD rate from 2.80% to 3.55% APY. iGObanking's CD rates often change dramatically. This shows how important it is not to let your CDs automatically renew. Don't assume the new CD rate will be competitive. For example, iGObanking's 1-year CD rate is only 1.00%.

Is it wise to lock into a 5-year CD? That's a tough question. Many expect interest rates to rise sharply in the next two years. Interest rates will rise, but no one knows when. It could be 6 months or it could be 5 years. A long-term CD with a small early withdrawal penalty is one way to hedge your bets. If rates don't rise, you're rewarded with a rate much better than any short-term CD rate. If we do see rates increase dramatically, a small early withdrawal penalty will reduce the cost of breaking the CD so you can invest it in a better paying account.

iGOBanking's early withdrawal penalty for long-term CDs is 180 days of interest (see their disclosure). This is a typical early withdrawal penalty for long-term CDs. If rates shoot up a year from now and you break the 3.55% CD, you'll lose half of your accrued interest. So instead of earning 3.55% for the year, your return will be around 1.77% which is quite comparable with many current 12-month CD rates.

Ally Bank's Very Small Early Withdrawal Penalty

I learned about Ally Bank's new early withdrawal penalty this week. For long-term CDs, it's the smallest penalty that I've seen at any bank or credit union. It's only 60 days of interest for any term. So if you get Ally's 3.15% 60-month CD, and you break it after 1 year, your return for the year would be around 2.63% which is much higher than any 12-month CD rate available nationwide.

This early withdrawal penalty seems too good to be true. I reviewed some potential gotchas in my Ally CD review. Readers noted one other potential gotcha. There's a possibility that Ally Bank could increase the early withdrawal penalty during the term of the CD. It would seem to me that the terms that you agree to when you buy a CD should remain in effect until the CD matures or if the bank fails. I do not know if Ally bank is contractually obligated to honor the early withdrawal penalty listed in the terms when you buy the CD. The OCC suggests that banks should abide by the CD account agreement. Perhaps we should save those Ally ads about underhanded and sneaky bankers. Increasing the early withdrawal penalty during the CD term would even be worse than not letting that TV girl ride her bike outside the 6-foot box.

Below are some of the best nationwide and local CD deals that are still active.

Best Nationwide CD Deals as of 1/31/10: Also listed are savings account promos with rate guarantee periods. The full list of nationwide CD rates is farther down.

  1. 2.25% 3-mo money market/checking promo at EverBank (account review)
  2. 2.50% 9-mo ($50K max) at Dime Savings Bank (account review)
  3. 1.77% 10-mo CD at EBSB Direct (account review)
  4. 2.22% 12-mo CD at Wings Financial CU, Limited Membership (account review)
  5. 2.10% 12-mo CD at Alliant CU (account review)
  6. 2.17% 24-mo Add-On CD at Northwest FCU (account review)
  7. 2.50% 30-mo CD at Astoria Federal Savings (account review)
  8. 3.00% 36-mo CD at Pentagon FCU (may change in Feb) (account review)
  9. 3.25% 48-mo CD at Pentagon FCU (may change in Feb) (account review)
  10. 3.15% 48-mo CD at Hudson City Savings Bank (account review)
  11. 3.65% 60-mo CD at Melrose CU (account review)
  12. 3.60% 60-mo CD at Apple FCU (account review)
  13. 3.55% 60-mo CD at iGObanking (account review)
  14. 3.50% 60-mo CD at Pentagon FCU (may change in Feb) (account review)
  15. 3.40% 60-mo CD at Hudson City Savings Bank (account review)
  16. 3.15% 60-mo Small-Penalty CD at Ally Bank (account review)
  17. 4.06% 84-mo CD (min $175K) at USAA Bank (account review)

Best Local CD Deals as of 1/31/10: Some of the best CD deals are from banks and credit unions that don't offer accounts nationwide. Refer to the recap section and the state index section to find all the recent local deals. Here are some of the best deals to note.

  1. 2.52% Money Market Account at South Florida FCU (account review)
  2. 2.50% Money Market Account (min $100K) at Georgia Primary Bank in Atlanta (account review)
  3. 1.90% Savings Account (5% for 1st $1K) at OMNIBANK in TX (account review)
  4. 2.22% 12-mo CD at Wings Financial CU in MN (account review)
  5. 2.00% 6-mo CD at Vision Bank in Dallas (account review)
  6. 2.00% 6-mo CD at United Financial Bank of Florida (account review)
  7. 3.00% 7-mo CD at NIH FCU in MD & DC - Limited Membership (account review)
  8. 2.25% 12-mo & under CD at Cecil Bank in MD (account review)
  9. 2.22% 12-mo CD at Cornerstone Bank & Trust in IL (account review)
  10. 2.01% 15-mo CD at Aspire FCU in NY, NJ, NH & VA (account review)
  11. 2.00% 15-mo CD at LA Financial Credit Union in CA & AZ (account review)
  12. 2.30% 16-mo Jumbo CD at Teachers FCU in NY (account review)
  13. 2.35% 17-mo CD at Community Bank of Broward in FL (account review)
  14. 2.40% 18-mo CD & 3.40% 44-mo CD at Crescent Bank & Trust in Louisiana (account review)
  15. 4.06% 48-mo CD & 2.52% 24-mo CD at Founders FCU in SC/NC (account review)
  16. 4.00% 60-mo CD at PFFCU in Philadelphia (account review)
  17. 3.80% 60-mo & 3.29% 48-mo CD at PrimeWay FCU in Houston (account review)
  18. 3.75% 60-mo & 3.45% 48-mo CD at Fidelity Bank of FL (account review)
  19. 3.60% 60-mo Jumbo CD at CEFCU in CA & IL (account review)
  20. 3.56% 72-mo CD at Broadway Federal Bank in Los Angeles (account review)

Reward Checking Accounts

I reported on two new reward checking accounts last week with yields of 3.04% and 4.02%. There were several disappointments this week. Royal Banks of Missouri had been offering the best nationwide reward checking yield of 4.30%. It's no longer a nationwide deal. The bank now only accepts applications from residents of Missouri. At least existing customers will continue to receive 4.30% APY. However, they're going to have to work a little harder. The account will soon require 15 debit card purchases a month rather than 10 (see post).

Another dissapointment was at Coulee Bank which announced they're cutting the reward checking yield from 4.04% to 3.33%. At least this continues to be available nationwide. Countybank not only cut its rate, but now the account appears to only be available for South Carolina residents. It had recently been available to much of the Southeast. When I first reported on this reward checking account in May 2009, it was nationally available.

To see all of the high yield reward checking accounts available throughout the nation, please refer to the reward checking section of DepositAccounts.com.

Recap for the Week - Links to This Week's Posts

Banking News

CD Deals - National

Savings/Checking Accounts - Nationwide

Checking/Savings Bonuses

Reward Checking Accounts

CD and Money Market Deals - Local

The rates listed below are based on Annual Percentage Yield (APY). No minimum balances are required unless noted. MMA next to the rates indicate a money market account. Most MMAs have check writing and ATM cards. Online savings accounts usually lack both of these. The top lists include banks and credit unions with broad availability and with minimums under $100,000. Previous weekly summaries are available at this page. Quick Links: Refer to the following links for the savings accounts and CDs that interest you: Liquid Account Rates: Savings Accounts, Reward Checking, Bank alternatives CD Rates: 3 Mo CDs, 6 Mo CDs, 9 Mo CDs, 12 Mo CDs, 18 Mo CDs, 24 Mo CDs, 36 Mo CDs, 48 Mo CDs, 60 Mo CDs, 84 Mo CDs, CDs by state Comments: read and discuss

As of January 31, 2010

Checking/Savings/Money Market Accounts:

3-Month Certificates of Deposit:

6-Month Certificates of Deposit:

9-Month Certificates of Deposit:

12-Month Certificates of Deposit:

18-Month Certificates of Deposit:



24-Month Certificates of Deposit:

36-Month Certificate of Deposit:

48-Month Certificate of Deposit:

60-Month Certificate of Deposit:

84-Month Certificate of Deposit:

Various Deposit Account Deals



High Yield Reward Checking Accounts - Open to All



Recent CD Specials at Local Credit Unions and Banks

Bank Account Alternatives

Historical Rates from the Federal Reserve (Federal funds, Treasury bills, CD's)


In order of date posted. - Sort by votes

Be the First to Comment


Post a Comment