Dedicated to Deposits: Deals, Data, and Discussion

Are Public Banks The Next Big Thing in Banking?


Are Public Banks The Next Big Thing in Banking?

While the furor over big bank fees continues and people hunt for alternatives, there's a little engine that could – the Bank of North Dakota. Founded in 1919, it is the nation's first and only publicly owned bank.

With $270 million in operating capital, BND is being looked at as a model worth replicating. Are publicly owned banks the next big thing in banking?

If Marc Armstrong has anything to do with it, they surely will be. Armstrong is the executive director of the Public Banking Institute, that has a mission to further the understanding, explore the possibilities, and facilitate the implementation of public banking at all levels -- local, regional, state, and national.

Seventeen states have introduced legislation for publicly owned banks or derivations, or for studies or task forces to determine how a publicly owned bank would operate in their jurisdiction, says Armstrong.

What exactly is a public bank? It is a financial institution owned by government entities, say a city, state or nation. The initial capital for a public bank often comes from a government appropriation or the proceeds of a loan arranged for the purpose of making the initial investment, but there are also other ways this money could be acquired, such as reinvesting money from idle state and local funds and by setting the bank up as a DBA of the state, making all the assets of the state assets of the bank, according to the Public Banking Institute.

Like a private bank, a public bank keeps money and issues credit. A big difference, if the government owns the bank, the profits go into public hands and offset the costs of government operations. There are other advantages, outlined on the Public Banking Institute's website. Rather than borrowing from Wall Street banks at 5 percent and having to worry about such things as credit ratings, interest rate swaps, and late fees, the state can fund its projects through its own bank, by backing the loans with its own revenues deposited in the bank with no interest having to be paid to itself, and until it can acquire the necessary deposits, it can borrow short-term from other banks at 0.2 percent.

Quite simply, public banks are about the public, and don't have to worry about shareholders obsessed about stock price and quarterly profits. “Private banks don't really have our interests at heart. It's about pocketing profits and taking lots of risks,” says Armstrong.

In public banking, profits are returned to the public in benefits like increased public services and reduced taxes. There's likely to be more profit too, because gazillions of dollars aren't going to fat cat bonuses for Wall Streeters. Employees of a publicly owned bank are public servants making civil service salaries.

How does the public banking system work?

In the example of BND, it is not a retail bank, per se, retail products are a tiny part of what they offer. They are a wholesale bank, or a “banker's bank,” as Armstrong calls it. BND helps local banks with capital requirements, partners with some 100 North Dakota financial institutions and participates in loans. BND creates loan programs that are rolled out through community banks. “If a small business needed $1 million to expand their business, they could apply through a community bank in the Bank of North Dakota program,” explains Armstrong, who says that some of the loans offered by BND are as low as 1% interest. “It's hard for small businesses to get operating loans typically, and not at that affordable rate. But banks make credit cards plentiful at 15-16 percent interest,” says Armstrong.

North Dakota residents can however, apply directly for student loans and residential mortgages. There are no branches of BND.

The majority of deposits come from tax collections and state fees.

Why the opposition?

So, with all the pluses, why aren't there more public banks? “There are roadblocks. Some people believe the government shouldn't be involved in banking, but yet they think it's okay that private banks have a monopoly and are in charge of the money supply after all the banking scams,” says Armstrong.

Then too, a lot of people don't understand that state and local governments can do public banking.

However, contends Armstrong, for all those who think public banking is a bad idea, BND's success is hard to ignore. It has low overhead, one central office of about 160 employees for the whole state, so it is extremely efficient relative to the revenue it produces for the state's general fund. And that contribution has been significant. According to the Public Banking Institute, BND has contributed more to the state budget over the last 15 years than oil taxes have generated and over the last decade, the BND has contributed over $300 million to the state. North Dakota, at 3.1 percent in February, has the lowest unemployment rate in the country. “If you give businesses loans, they can create jobs. Money is being used there to serve people, not bankers. Tax revenues are being put to work,” says Armstrong.

There's a lot of potential in public banking – it may be the best kept secret in banking. But word is getting out. Says Armstrong, “People are going to gradually recognize the benefits. I believe it will be the counties and smaller states that will be the first to go for this.”



Related Posts

Comments

Please log in to comment on this post.

15 Comments.
Comment #1 by Apache posted on
Apache
I am very confused about this Public Bank issue.  Is the money Federally Insured like other accounts in banks?  I read this article and the link to the other and none speak about federal insurance.  Are Public banks immune from going under??  Not quite sure I understand what they really are.  Thanks!

3
Comment #3 by Apache posted on
Apache
Xthe:  Nice to be missed but I didn't know I was gone.  :)  Did Ken cancel all my posts?

1
Comment #4 by tightwad posted on
tightwad
$270 in operating capital?

1
Comment #5 by ILsaver posted on
ILsaver
The man with these ideas obviously has not been to my home state of IL, nor has he grasped the corruption and ineptness of Washington DC.

 

I found the following line to be amusing:

"Rather than borrowing from Wall Street banks at 5 percent and having to worry about such things as credit ratings, interest rate swaps, and late fees, the state can fund its projects through its own bank..."

Does this gentleman realize that the State of IL has NOT been worrying about credit ratings and has, with the full intention of the Democrats running the state, increased personal taxes substantially while spending us further into oblivion, with only the poor suffering as a result?

 

And you want to put another responsibility into the hands of those who can't handle what they presently have?

 

The same holds true for the management of the dying postal service, and how wonderfully politicians have handled that.

 

Can we please be serious about the practicality of such ideas?  North Dakota may be a wonderful state, but its employment figures have more to do with abundant natural resources there and lack of population, than anything a new banking system might have contributed.

8
Comment #7 by Maecl posted on
Maecl
All I can say is "The less government the better."

6
Comment #8 by Apache posted on
Apache
xthe:  not too busy "selling" cherry pies.  Too busy trying to find some to EAT!

BTW:  Does anyone know the answer to my question?  Are Public banks insured??  Thanks!

1
Comment #9 by Jeremy posted on
Jeremy
From BND's FAQ, "In contrast to most commercial banks, Bank of North Dakota is not a member of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC). North Dakota Century Code 6-09-10 provides that all BND deposits are guaranteed by the full faith and credit of the State of North Dakota." http://banknd.nd.gov/about_BND/pdfs/faqs.pdf

3
Comment #11 by Apache posted on
Apache
DANN:  Thanks!  I wonder if they sell CDs like other banks?

1
Comment #12 by strikethree posted on
strikethree
Maecl:

I'm not a fan of big government but we saw what happens in 2008 when we let the private banks just do whatever they want.

They get bigger (through mergers) and they over-leverage. 

Then, the government (through taxpayer money) had to bail them out because they were too big to fail.

I have mixed feelings about public banks... but, at this point, I'm tired of seeing $100 mil bonuses go to Wall Street Execs for FAILING. These kinds of salaries likely won't be given in public banks. It'll also be nice to see more competition in the arena.

2
Comment #14 by Apache posted on
Apache
Ok Danny Boy, you are not fooling anyone by quick changing your name!  The Apple Pie always gives you away.  Quit with the pie thing.  I am not near a bakery!!  I would gladly give up a delicious CHERRY pie for a decent CD rate!

1
Comment #15 by Apache posted on
Apache
Someone must be bored today and playing with the "Delete" button.  Why are we being treated like "children"?  Since when is Ken so strict about what can and cannot be posted?  I haven't read a post which breaks the "comment policy".  I think the least the "deleter" can do is tell us WHAT we are posting that is so bad so we won't keep repeating the problems.  Thank you.

1
Comment #16 by Maecl posted on
Maecl
Strikethree:

I agree banks contributed to the financial crisis, and no one wants them to get a bonus for failure.

However the government allowed the mergers, wanted banks to give bad loans, created Fannie & Freddie, and on it goes.

2
Comment #18 by Apache posted on
Apache
Opa:  I used to use Capital One some years ago but I am trying to find banks and cus closer to my locality.  They used to have really good rates which beat local banks but not so good from what I have seen lately.  I'll check out their webpage for "just in case".  Thanks for the info.

1
Comment #19 by Apache posted on
Apache
Opa:  I just checked Capital One's CD rates.  Phew!!!  Not like in the good ole days!  Thanks but no thanks.  I need to gas up the car and get on the road again.

2
Comment #21 by Apache posted on
Apache
opa:  Yes I know.  It's the restaurant right next to the bank I use. But only on certain days.  Good CD rates and cherry pie to boot!  Can't do better than that unless I get there for breakfast and can get the grits and ham!

1