Back to Bank and Credit Union Reviews
Reply
Thursday, October 25, 2012 - 10:43 AM

CD Rates And Availability

Montauk Credit Union (3 stars)
Thanks to this invaluable website, and the reviewers, I knew enough to call Montauk CU to find out if they were accepting new deposits in CD's, before driving 150 miles (each way) to apply for membership, which must be done in person. As of 10/23/12, they were not. The woman with whom I spoke politely informed me that their Board (of Directors, I believe) meets the end of the month (each month, if I recall correctly), and decides then whether or not to accept new deposits. She suggested I call back after November 1st to check again then.                      It would be helpful if the credit union made the situation clear on its website, preferably above the interest rate section, which states "rates in effect as of 09/20/2012". Of course, it also states that rates are "subject to change without notice", so it's always advisable to call to confirm rates, as this website suggests.                                     

Question: Does anyone know what "Under supervision of the NY State Banking Dept." means? That line is right under the credit union's name on its website. Does it mean they were in financial difficulty and the state stepped in to supervise them, or is that a stock phrase which any state-chartered CU might use?

Thanks to all who provided information.
4
johnnyrottenjohnnyrotten1 posts since
Oct 25, 2012
Rep Points: 4
1. Thursday, October 25, 2012 - 4:05 PM
Thanks for providing the update on Montauk's CD status. Sorry to see they are still not accepting new deposits. I don't know why they don't mention this on their website.

About the line "under supervision of the NY State Banking Dept.", I believe their intent is to show that they are a state-chartered credit union with this department being their primary regulator. They appear to be financially healthy. The financial data that we have shows them to be very healthy with a 5 star rating (out of 5).

The credit union is small with only 8 employees.
2
KenBDGKenBDG5,146 posts since
Nov 29, 2009
Rep Points: 117,030
2. Friday, October 26, 2012 - 5:38 PM
Correct. Here's the list of financial institutions they supervise - NYSBD: Institutions We Supervise
1
cactuscactus48 posts since
Jan 17, 2010
Rep Points: 339
Reply