High-Yield Reward Checking Account at an Iowa Bank (State Bank of Toledo)
Update 5/16/11: The top rate has fallen to 1.51% APY. See bottom of post for the rate history.
State Bank of Toledo is offering a reward checking account called Hometown Reward Checking. It offers 1.51% APY for balances up to $25,000 (0.50% for above) and up to $25 of ATM fee refunds per month if you meet the typical reward checking requirements: 1) 10 check card transactions per month, 2) one direct deposit or ACH auto debit per month, and 3) receive electronic statements. If you don't meet these requirements, the rate falls to 0.15% APY. There are no monthly service charges regardless of meeting these requirements. It requires a minimum opening deposit of $100, but no there's no minimum balance requirement.
You can apply online without a branch visit. After you submit the application online, they'll send you a signature card that must be signed and notarized. I was also told you can be in any state to apply.
NOTE: A reader advised me that you must contact State Bank of Toledo if you want to wire funds. One cannot just use State Bank of Toledo's routing number. They have a correspondence bank (a banker's bank) in Madison, Wisconsin. (1/3/08)
The bank is located in Toledo, Iowa which is between Des Moines and Cedar Rapids. It has been FDIC insured since 1934 (FDIC Certificate # 4514). The bank has a 3 out of 5 star rating (performing) at Bankrate.com based on 12/31/06 financial data.
For other reward checking accounts in other parts of the country, please see my best checking account post.
Rate History:
- 05/16/11: 1.51% APY up to $25K; 0.50% over; 0.15% base
- 12/30/10: 2.01% APY up to $25K
- 01/19/10: 2.51% APY up to $25K; 1.00% over; 0.25% base
- 09/09/09: 2.51% APY
- 10/15/08: 3.01% APY
- 03/21/08: 4.01% APY
- 12/14/07: 5.01% APY for up to $70K (Please see this post for more details)
- 06/21/07: 6.01% APY for all balances
1. They do a hard pull.
2. They have on-line bill-pay.
3. The statement period is from the 16th through the 15th, so take that into consideration for check card transactions, etc.
4. Their toll-free number is 1-877-484-5725.
do they charge for checks?
do they do pod w/poa?
what is the minimum or limit ofd $ to earn the 6% apy?
3 stars vs 5 stars rateing? should one be concerened putting money with them
Before I called this bank on June 21st, I had sent them an email. They finally responded on June 29th. It confirms what I was told on the phone. The customer rep apologized for the delay and said that they're overwhelmed by the number of emails from all over the US. Here's the rest of the email response:
There is no limit on the amount you may deposit into this account. It takes $100 deposit to open the account but once it is opened you may have as little or as much as you like as a balance. It is possible to apply from anywhere in the U.S. for this account. Please apply online and fill out the application completely.
What I'm concerned about is, do they know what they're doing? Yes, we are safe due to FDIC, but from the link to Bankrate they don't have a great rating, and they could get money into this account that amounts to who knows, 1/3 of the amount they already have on deposit?
It seems to me like gambling; I guess one factor in these rewards checking deals is the bank is hoping you don't meet the requirements and so they will only have to pay 0.25%. This is a gamble they're going to lose, because you have a bunch of rate-chasing fanatics (including me) who keep track of all these requirements and are expert at making sure they get met. So can they invest this much new money profitably and safely? And then what happens if they drop the rate and it all goes flying out again? Will they have to be taken over by the FDIC? I don't want to take down a little bank and maybe harm the community where they are. I have an account at BOA where I get 5.37%, and I have the FNBO Direct account paying 6% (for now). So I don't need the 6.01% if it's going to harm them.
If the Bank of Toledo has a plan for what to do with the money, the cost savings the vendor talks about ARE going to happen. They are hardly going to have to worry at all about costs, because these are going to be large, low-cost accounts.
No teller-assisted transactions, no mailings, a few electronic transactions, maybe some checks that will just be put in the clearing system, but the checks will probably be pretty large and few in number because the foreign customers will probably write their small checks on their local banks.
But I can see these people easily getting in another $10 million or $20 million or more (maybe much more) as a result of this. 200 people putting in $100,000 each, that's $20 million right there, and that's over 25% of their total deposits as of March 31.
1. This was asked before but I didn't see an answer, was there any charge for checks?
2. For automatic ACH, I assume that there wouldn't be any upper limit ie. $10 which is the minimum for most bank would meet the requirement? anyone has actual experience?
3. Anyone has any experience with the bank's online billpay. Is it similar to Salem Five whereas the money does not get debited until the vendor is paid not when you schedule it or is it debited as soon as you schedule the transactions?
4. Just curious though what is with the 10 debit transactions? Do banks get some fees ie. revenue out of this from vendors? I guess I still don't see the financial picture ie. profits for these types of account despite evidence to the contrary of banks jumping in like lemmings every day.
For most credit card transaction merchants pay a % of the charge. On Debit cards they pay a processing fee plus % of the charges. The Visa/MC and banks stand on this was that it was converting a check from paper to electronic and granteing that the check was good and court up held this notion.
So for example BOA makes more money if you use your debit card over your BOA issued credit card for the same transaction. It ends up being about 35 cents more plus the consumer get no float on the money either.
The Online billpay is very good. Its free (no longer need 3 bills paid per month) and you can schedule the payments for the date they are due for merchants like visa and mc banks that take electronic payments. Also give you the option of receiving bills electronically. Nice interface. Same as first internet bank of indiana.
It has been about a month since I first posted on it, and it remains open to all. So that's a good sign.
Does anyone have any ideas on how to meet this requirement via automated means? (i.e. online)
Please don't bother with the account if you are not going to use the debit card. Speaking of which, I have yet to receive my card as it takes 2-4 weeks to receive it after sending them the written application, which they received first week of July. However, they are giving me the reward rate in my second month even though I won't meet the requirements since I don't have a card yet.
You can't link external accounts from within the site so you must push/pull from an external account. They quickly credit the deposits. Am loving this bank.
The rumor on FatWallet is that they are going to STOP permitting POD and beneficiary accounts (and this will apply to existing accounts as of the end of September). This will limit the FDIC insurance to 100k unless you are married. Haven't received any official notice yet, so its just a rumor for now. :)
Glad to see this bank is still going strong with this checking account after 3 months since my first report on them.
It'll be interesting to see how these reward checking accounts will change their rates after the Fed rate cut. If they can at least maintain 50 basis points above the top online savings account rates, it'll be worth the hassles.
Also according to the bank website one of the 3 conditions is that you: "Receive Electronic Statement". Well after applying I found out that you "receive" your statement by *logging into* the website once a month or you don't meet the conditions. Unlike the 1st two conditions this one is strictly a "gotcha" clause. The only "benefit" to them of this clause is that they know that sooner or later you'll forget and then they can legally steal ~$130 from you for every month that you would have otherwise qualified and have $70k in there. Yes, I know all the Rewards Checking acts have this sleazy policy but this bank pretends it doesn't and then you get the bad news after you apply.