I'm Looking For Some Feedback

I'm looking for some feedback.  Ally Bank emailed me asking me to renew my 12 month CD with .25% loyalty bump.  So I read here that they offered .5 loyalty bump to some accounts and I chatted with them saying I want this .5% loyalty bump also and they will get back to me within 48 hours.  If they offer it to me should I take the 1 year 1.50% with .5% loyalty bump or 2 year CD @ 1.99% and .5% loyalty bump with the chance to raise my rate one time at some point in the future?  I have other offers at slightly better rates, but would keep it @ Ally if they offered the above deal based on convience.