SmartyPig Reviews

Average Rating:
Based on 26 review

Amazing Website Literally Life Changing

Posted by: |

I have banked with smartypig for several years now. Hardly ever have any issues. Site is mostly stable and quality experience. Some bugginess but not bad. I set up savings goals there and automatic withdrawals from my personal checking and the goals stack up over time. It's a amazing way to budget and save money and reach many savings goals. I cannot imagine life without this site. It has turned me into such a great saver and made me so financially secure. HIGHLY recommend. The poor reviews might be sketchy customer service or w/e but the site just works and I never need to use customer support since the site is easy to use without help. There's no fees and you just make money on interest on smartypig. Win win. Other reviewers mentioned being called a bot by the login screen of - well then they aren't passing the captcha test! Just click on the little animal that is facing upward, not on the upside down or sideways animals. Not rocket science! Maybe these reviewers are bad review bots!

Smartypig Is Not Smart, They Are Just Pigs

Posted by: |

SmartyPig's website says they will pay a higher interest rate as long as your account is no more than $10,000. So I deposited $10,000. At the end of that month, they paid the lower interest rate. When I asked them why, they said that they calculated the interest rate based on what my balance was going to be after they deposited the interest. WTF?

They are not SmartyPigs, they are DumbPigs, so they lost a customer.

Horrible - Don‘T Do It

After opening the account - just like one reviewer said, you couldn’t get back in, continually locked out saying I was a robo guy. You try to call customer service during business hours and they don’t even put you on hold, they just hang up after their call spiel. You can’t chat or email because you have to be logged into the account to use the chat feature. They ask for A LOT of personal information and now I’m trying desperately to find out how to close it. Sallie Mae’s bank website gives the same (only 1) phone number that no one answers - so I’m trying to find someone to call at Sallie Mae. Don’t waste your time with the high APY, thankfully I didn’t deposit any money, but they have a lot of personal info.

Awful - I Don't Trust Them

Posted by: |

I started an account because of their 'high' interest rate at the time.
The site looks childish, but I was able to create an account without issues. I linked my other bank account to make an initial deposit. 5 days later, I saw the small deposits (old verification method) and attempted to login to my SmartyPig account. The site continually called me a 'bot' (even with the old picture verification).
Days later, I verified my password that I set up and tried it again. Same result - I'm a 'bot'.
So, figuring I wrote down my password wrong, I had it reset (through the site). Reset the password, waited 5-10 minutes as recommended (why?!?) and tried again. Same thing! I finally called to cancel my account and was told "the website is down, even we can't log in" and to call later. Really. There was no notice or warning on the website!

Don't trust your money with this bank. This experience is making me think this is a data collection site and I'm going to put a notice on my linked bank and credit agencies.


Posted by: |

The buffoonery of this place is stunning. I contacted support to ask them how I could transfer money from my bank into smartypig. I did not want to initiate that transfer from within smartypig. One support person said that I could not do it that way. Another person said that I could. I said that if I cannot transfer money from my bank account into smartypig then they can close my account. Within seconds they closed my account as another support person said that I could transfer money from my bank account. Apparently they are not interested in my business, so I will take my business elsewhere.

Not the best to bank with

I've been using Smarty Pig for about 3 years now and they were pretty good until they switched to using Sallie Mae for their services. Since they've switched I seem to always have issues logging into my account, always having to reset my password every time I go to login even when I know my password is right. And I despise the fact that in order to reset my password I have to call customer service versus being able to have a link sent to my email or have a code texted or emailed to me in order to reset it. I wouldn't have such an issue with having to call customer service if it weren't for the fact that usually when I call customer service nobody picks up and they require me to leave a message. And usually they don't call you back until days later. To me this is a bit alarming because it makes me feel like if I can't get access to my own money who knows what they could be doing to it in the time they get around to calling me to help me reset my password. This means I can't check my account balance or see if anyone's tried to compromise my account in any way. I also do not care for the fact that with the savings account it takes forever the funds to clear. If I put money in my savings account on the first of the month it should not take until halfway through the month for the funds to be cleared for me to be able to make any changes with whatever money I have in my account.

Smarty Pig for Savings

I use Smarty Pig for my family's savings goals. I like using Smarty Pig the most because I can setup automated withdrawals. I set them to cooincide with our pay periods. Also being able to set up multiple accounts/savings goals is a huge plus. I can manage funds for vacation, emergency, etc all under one umbrella account. Each withdrawal is seperate but I don't have the hassle of so much paperwork like at a brick and mortar bank when opening/closing goals. A few things that I don't like about Smarty Pig include the fact that there is no option for debit cards. This relates to the second complaint; that if an emergency did occur it's very difficult to get access to your funds. When you have automated withdrawals you can't cancel a goal when a draft is pending, which could take days.

Terrible Since They Moved To Sallie Mae!

I've had an account with Smarty Pig for years, and recommended it to dozens of people. I loved their old system and platform, and didn't even mind their three day transfer process. Since switching to Sallie Mae, they have messed up my account balance on more than one occasion. Their system has gotten slower, and their customer service has gotten terrible. I ultimately had to close my account as I no longer have confidence that they are managing and monitoring accounts - I had to call multiple times to confirm the amount I had saved. They wouldn't even confirm my balances before closing, and I'm no longer allowed to log in to monitor the transfer while I wait for the three days. I'm unfortunately glad to be rid of them.

Don't Save At This Bank

Smarty pig honestly sucks. Sure they're able to save your money without strings attached but they have this shitty policy of closing your account after 5 bushiness days and when you do transfer your money, it takes two business days. So if you need your money at a specific time, do not save your money with this bank. I'm just so frustrated with them because I'm still waiting for my funds to come through due to shit policy.

SmartyPig Savings Account

Posted by: |

I became a Smarty Pig customer last year 2014 and my account was earning 1% APY. When I first started, I was very intrigued with how many categories it allowed you to save for. When I first opened my account, I had a new car, home, entertainment, kids' college fund, and travel category. Smarty Pig allows you to put the amount that you want to save for each category, known as your goal. Then it allows you to put when you expect to make that goal. Next it informs you of the percentage that you are in your goal. For instance, if you have a new car category and the goal is $15,000 and you put $2,000 in, your percentage would be 13.33%. So you have 86.67% left to save until you meet your goal. I also had to call customer service one day about something, and they are very personable. They treat their customers with care and kindness. I also like the way that you can redeem your savings. One good way is the retailer gift card, where you can earn up to 11% cash back. I would recommend Smarty Pig to anyone.

Fun Way To Save, But Beware...

If you want your funds by a specific date, make sure your goal is closed at least 10 days before you need them. I made the mistake of adding to my goal, thinking I'll have even more money saved for vacation, only to learn it takes 5 business days to actually close your goal from the time they receive your last payment. And another few days to actually get your money back into your account. Looks like I'll get mine AFTER vacation is over. Buzz kill for sure.

Smartypig very smart

Posted by: |

I heard of SmartyPig in 2010 on several different financial blogs because their interest rates were one of the highest at that time. Their website is very user friendly and I had no trouble signing up and transferring money to/from my checking account. I really liked how you can designate different savings goals and share those goals with people you choose on social media. Additionally, you are able to purchase gift cards which would give you higher value than if you were to transfer money to the checking account. I had several different saving goals in my SmartyPig account and it helped to see each of them grow. I cannot think of any feature I do not like about my SmartyPig account, except maybe the interest rate which has not changed much since 2010; however, I guess that is the case with every bank these days.

Smarty Pig is Simple and Pays Interest

Posted by: |

There is no simpler way to save online that through Smarty Pig. I love that I don't have to have much money to earn interest, even if I'm only making a few cents. I also love that I can have the money returned to me either back into my traditional bank, or through gift cards, with even more bonus money added on.

I wish the withdrawals were easier, since I have my emergency fund saved with them. It takes 7 business days, which can be rough.

Great for savings account

Posted by: |

I'm not sure how most savings accounts work but I love the fact that Smarty Pig accrues interest every quarter rather than providing interest once a year. I've been using this site as my online savings account for about a year or so now to save up money to buy a new car as well as for an apartment and I've recommended it to several people. I also love that it doesn't require a large amount of money set aside in order to open up a savings account and that I can set up several different savings accounts under one account for different needs. I have two separate savings accounts for my car savings and apartment savings as well as a vacation savings which makes it easier to keep all of my fund separate that way I don't end up dabbling in my funds and accidentally spending money that wasn't supposed to be spent. The fact that I also transfer my money into my bank account or turn all or a portion of my money into a gift card is a plus as well. Because I want to save a certain amount of money for some things the tracking of how close I am to my goal makes it easier for me to see how close I am to my financial goals.

Love Smartypig!

Posted by: |

I've been using Smartypig for over 18 months now and I love them! I love being able to set up individual goals. I try to always keep a small "emergency fund," and then also set up ahead of time for birthdays, holidays, vacations, etc. The interest rate is very competitive, it's completely free, and it's actually FUN! I've never been a good saver (still struggle!), but Smartypig helps a lot. I take money in and out all the time and I've never had a problem. There is sometimes up to a 2-wk wait after deposit to be able to turn around and withdraw, but that has been good for us b/c we aren't as likely to spend what's in there. When we do move money back into our BBT Checking account (more than we should!), it's always been very fast, within 24-48 hours. I just love this bank/website and I recommend it to everyone!

Not Up To The Mark

Posted by: |

I tried to open an account and kept getting an error "Your username has not been recognized"  contacted support and its been several iterations with them.  while they are polite, i do not think they are very competent. 

I think this is not yet a fully mature company and they still have a lot of work cut out for them.  i am now hesitant to park my money with them.


Love Smartypig

Posted by: |

I have nothing but great things to say about Smartypig. Anytime I have locked myself out of my account, I am always easily let back in by answering my security questions. I haven't had the need to talk with the bank that actually holds the money I have with Smartypig, so I have no idea if they are easy to work with. I have also been able to get my money out in partial amounts or my entire goal. It might take a day or so to get your money into your account, but I like that. I always have trouble saving money in a savings account with my normal bank because it is hooked to my checking. I like having this separateness, so I am okay with the day or so it takes to get my money. I also love being able to see what percentage I am to my goal, as well as the ability to add money using their mobile app! I haven't use put my money into a gift card, but the ability to get cash back from doing so is making it something I will definitely look into in the future!! I definitely recommend Smartypig to anyone!

I Like Smartypig

I think Smartypig is a fun and creative way to allocate funds and save for goals.  I also like the idea of being able to use social networking sites to publicize your goals and accept gifts and donations to what you are saving for.  Their interest rate is pretty decent compared to what's out there now.  I would recommend using Smartypig for anyone interested who want to have fun with savings.

The Worst Choice Ever!

Posted by: |

I wish I could give "negative" stars to Smartypig.  Even one star is too many.  There is nothing smarty about this pig. 

My account has been locked for a week now for the reasons that I don't know.  I am not even provided any explanation.  Each and every time I contact the customer service, I am told that the account is being "reviewed" by BBVA (the "real" bank that SmartyPig operates with), and that someone is going to contact me.  That's all I got!  Even Smartypig is unable to get into my account, and they don't know what BBVA is doing.  Not only I can't get any explanation from Smartypig, they also don't provide any contact information where I can seek an explanation.  My money is being held up by someone for some reason and I am denied to have access to it!  Is this legal?!  In any case I deserve an explanation, which would be provided If I had chosen a reliable financial choice over Smartypig.

As of now (after a week), noone has gotton back to me yet, and Smartypig is (apparently) unable to do anything until BBVA gets back to them (or to me).  All I have been told is to wait.  Why and how long, no clue...  I didn't know Smartypig was just a puppet company of a bank, with no power over that bank.  I would certainly have never chosen Smartypig if I had known I could be locked out of my own account indefinetely for the reasons that even the Smartypig customer service is unaware.

I am currently planning to contact BBVA (found the contact info in Google).  I am also considering to pass this issue to an attorney.

Awful - Stay Away From Smarty Pig

Posted by: |

Be aware that smarty pig doesnt actually hold your money, and should there be any problem with your account, or should you need to withdraw funds, you have to jump through hoops. They wont even give you a contact number at BBVA Compass - the bank that holds the funds -- they tell you to hang by the phone and the bank will call you. Inexcusable. I've been locked out of my account twice in a week and both times the bank has taken 2 DAYS to contact me to resolve the isue.

Wacky, Yes, But Good Rate

Posted by: |

If you can put up with the hoops, they do have a decent rate compared to other options out there. It's an interesting concept, and I like the original idea of having the availability of different categories of savings to keep yourself organized. But, they've dropped the rate steadily (like everyone) such that it's no longer such a good deal. Additionally, they've added "features" like a prepaid card that I am suspicious will add more to their revenue stream than to their depositors' wallets. Still, it's worth a look.

Very Wacky System

Posted by: |

They have a very wacky and confusing system of "savings goals." It appears designed to lock you in to them, and make you jump through a bunch of hoops in order to get the promised rates. I became very frustrated with this scheme and cancelled my account.

The financial institution, product, and APY (Annual Percentage Yield) data displayed on this website is gathered from various sources and may not reflect all of the offers available in your region. Although we strive to provide the most accurate data possible, we cannot guarantee its accuracy. The content displayed is for general information purposes only; always verify account details and availability with the financial institution before opening an account. Contact [email protected] to report inaccurate info or to request offers be included in this website. We are not affiliated with the financial institutions included in this website.