Flagstar Savings At 5.55% APY With $25,000+ Balance, 5 Month Guarantee

sunnyismoney
  |     |   26 posts since 2024

$15 monthly service charge, waived with $10,000 average daily balance OR with a Flagstar personal checking account. And after five months the current tiered interest rate maxes out at 2% APY for $100,000 and above. If your account is closed within six months of opening, you are subject to a $30 early closing fee and possible forfeiture of any interest you’ve earned on the account.need to bring new $

fdic
  |     |   250 posts since 2022
You can get better terms from the old MBD account (same bank), that also gives 5.55 and has none of this BS
sunnyismoney
  |     |   26 posts since 2024
who is MBD?
sunnyismoney
  |     |   26 posts since 2024
when I called my banking direct aka MBD in April 2024-they told me do not allow charities as beneficiaries & only allow 3 beneficiaries. pain in the ass as took too long for them to open the acct & for me to fund; so, went with Flagstar which was much smoother-allows charities & 5 beneficiaries.
fdic
  |     |   250 posts since 2022
sunnyismoney, they are both the same bank now.
I was thinking of opening a second account and called MBD as I was interested in doing another app online and getting hit with another Chex. They transferred me to the Flagstar virtual branch. Basically, you get personalized service and dont have to fill up applications online. This guy said he cant offer me the MBD account but can offer me the Flagstar one. He highlighted the rate guarantee and all that but didnt tell me about the fees etc. Anyways, I opened the Flagstar account and later when I figured out the fees, I was a bit upset and was going to close it but then ended opening a flagstar checking to avoid the fees.

I am still keeping my money in MBD though. According to FDIC, you can distribute your money as you like amongst different accounts with a bank. As long as you have n beneficiaries, you can have n x $250k insurance
fdic
  |     |   250 posts since 2022
Also from what they told me, they dont care too much about new money. They were saying even though they say that they have no systems/coding to detect that
sunnyismoney
  |     |   26 posts since 2024
fdic-yes, I thought u knew from my comment that I knew/know that my banking direct is the same as MBD. by the way, what do u guys get out of using letters that many people have no idea what u mean? what do u mean by n beneficiaries? what does the letter n mean? thanks
by the way-P - D is correct-max coverage is 1.25 mil
Ally6770
  |     |   4,315 posts since 2010
My credit union matched this for 6 months and ends for me in Oct. They matched it the first of May. I have been a member since my 6.5% reward checking on $25,000 stopped in 2010.
sunnyismoney
  |     |   26 posts since 2024
Ally-how do u mean they matched it cause MBD nor Flagstar were not offering 5.55 apy in May
_DAdefender
  |     |   17 posts since 2023
My Banking Direct has been paying 5.55% APY on its savings account since the first half of April.
RichReg
  |     |   153 posts since 2012
@_DAdefender;
Nice while it lasted, but not anymore.. Looks like Poopy Bank wins.
https://www.mybankingdirect.com/
_DAdefender
  |     |   17 posts since 2023
My savings account with My Banking Direct is still showing a 5.41% APR (5.55% APY). Let's see how many hours that lasts.
fdic
  |     |   250 posts since 2022
DADefender/RichReg, do you know when MBD changed the rate on the website. My account also shows the same as of now 5.41 APR (5.55 APY).

I actually have both accounts, MBD as well as Flagstar and moving money between them is just an internal transfer. I preferred MBD so far because of the no drama with the fees, etc.
RichReg
  |     |   153 posts since 2012
Change just happened this morning. Don’t hold your breath for your rate staying at the 5.55%….according to MBD customer service, they aren’t grandfathering anyone.
fdic
  |     |   250 posts since 2022
Btw, I had pretty crappy experience with Poopy bank. My app got stuck because of some system issues on their side (I did it late on Friday or a Saturday) and their CS was horrible, lied to me multiple times, will put me on hold forever, etc. and when I filed a complaint, their top clown Michael Chen or something sent me a generic PR reply which instead of addressing my specific complaints just said how great their bank and their CS is. I sent him some choice words via FDIC (their regulator). I forgot exactly what I said, something like Chief Tu*d Officer at Poopy bank, but long story short, I am banned for life from Poopy :)
I guess they were getting so many applications that they didnt care of about a few falling through the cracks.
fdic
  |     |   250 posts since 2022
RichReg, thanks. Just called them as well and told them a notification would have been nice.
Most probably it will update on the accounts tonight.

I am going to move my money to my Flagstar account before Eod today. Waiting on them to confirm that they are still not enforcing the "new money" clause for Flagstar accounts before I do that. If they dont confirm, then I will pull my money back to Marcus which is at 5.50 (with referrals). That way I will get at least 2 days of free interest as well.
fdic
  |     |   250 posts since 2022
In the past, I always found the MBD call center folks to be very helpful.

I dont know about Flagstar bank overall but Flagstar also has a virtual branch with folks based in MI and they are super helpful/motivated too. I called the person who had helped me open the account (all on phone without doing any online applications) and he confirmed that they are not enforcing "new money" clause at all. He also offered to open a new account so that the rate guarantee applies from today instead of like from 3 weeks ago and said he will take care of adding the same beneficiaries too.
RichReg
  |     |   153 posts since 2012
@fdic;
RE: New Money;
Just came from my local branch, so rest easy.....they're NOT requiring that.
(I also believe today is the last day to get the 5.55% 5-month guarantee)
Rickny
  |     |   1,299 posts since 2017
If your account is closed within six months of opening, you are subject to a $30 early closing fee and possible forfeiture of any interest you’ve earned on the account.
  So rate can go down after 5 months and if you close before 6 months you have to pay the early closing fee.
fdic
  |     |   250 posts since 2022
RickNY, to get around that, I opened a Flagstar checking as well. It has no fees and it also waives the fees for Flagstar Savings accounts. This way you can reduce your Flagstar Savings to $1 (if you have to) and not worry about monthly or early closing fees
Rickny
  |     |   1,299 posts since 2017
Not to question your comment but I cut and pasted the closing fee. If you confirmed the fee is wavied then you have no worries.  I also don't like the 25k min.

I have an account at Poppy which had a 6 month guarantee that expired for me but they are still paying 5.5%.  They currently have a 3 month guarantee @5.5%
fdic
  |     |   250 posts since 2022
RickNY, it is good that you highlighted the fee trap, I didnt like Flagstar either at first because of the same reasons. MBD is/was much simpler with no fees and no rate tiers.

I just thought I will mention the workaround for someone who still wants Flagstar as it is very easy to move money from MBD to Flagstar.

Btw, I tried Poppy too but it didnt work out, I posted my experience above :)
Poppy reminded me of CFG when they first became the bank with the highest rate. They got inundated with so many applications that they had no way to handle it. Some like me got hold of a good agent and sailed through but I heard lot of crappy complaints from quite a few other folks.
Rickny
  |     |   1,299 posts since 2017
I'm sure many institutions (especially small ones) have problems with being overwhelmed when the offer a great rate that is plastered over the internet. I had bo problems with Poppy.  Many years ago Penfed offered a 10 year 5% CD that was much higher than other institutions. They were inundated with calls and I couldn't get through. I remember others here unable to contact Penfed via phone.
  I prefer banks that I can do business easily online.  I find NASB's CD opening process to be very easy on line and they communicate the process via email. I started the process at noon  to open an NASB and the CD was open and funded via ACH at 5:00 today.
sunnyismoney
  |     |   26 posts since 2024
Rickny
what is NASB
fdic
  |     |   250 posts since 2022
NASB 5.30 APY currently
https://www.nasb.com/
Rickny
  |     |   1,299 posts since 2017
North America Savings Bank. They call themselves NASB and the site is NSAB.COM. One correction.. The account for the CD was opened and has the amount for the CD listed but they haven't pulled the funds yet.
RichReg
  |     |   153 posts since 2012
Looks like I was wrong about Flagstar's in-house 5.55% Promo.
Still ongoing...but I am concerned. Opened one of those yesterday and the
5.55% rate still isn't showing. Maybe it takes a day or two.

RE: The fee after 5 months; at this point the new rate on that MBD account is 5.45 APY. Technically, if you open the current $25K promo account in the middle of the period you'll have a few extra weeks of promo time, because I don't think they change your rate 'til the end of the month. My impression is its easy to get around things @ Flagstar, so I'm sure if you had to, you could get out with minimal damage. Question becomes: how bad could their new rate really be once the promo ends compared to others?

As far as Poopy bank goes, yeah, try getting out of there when the rate drops. They don't give you many options; save their own ACH service. Unless you go into a branch office in CA., you'd better have a fairly efficient 3rd party ready to pull funds.
Rickny
  |     |   1,299 posts since 2017
You can always pull from Poppy from other bank's when their rates go down. Chase you can pull up to 100k or open a CD or other account that allows you to pull a large amount of funds from Poppy. 
As with any bank, I always make sure I can move my funds quickly.

Remember,  if you close your account before 6 months you have to pay a $30 fee except the exception FDIC noted.  And after 5 months what will the rate be?  Elements CU had a guarantee that was 2.3% years ago. The date the guarantee ended went to.3%.
badnarc
  |     |   72 posts since 2023
People, just to keep you up to date on a bank that is on the verge of collapse. I opened an account at MBD when they first offered the 5.55% with my daughter as joint owner. Easy to open, got the 5.55% rate, and all went well until July when they dropped the rate to 5.45%. A few days later Flagstar (Same bank) offered an account for 5.55% guaranteed for 6 months. Tried opening an account on line numerous times with my daughter as joint owner and every appication was "Unable to verify information". Finally opened an account in my name only intending to add my daughter as joint owner. My account was approved and I moved $10 to it from my MBD account. Both the MBD and Flagstar accounts show up together on my website so was easy to do. Then I moved $50,000 from MBD to Flagstar easily BUT did not get the 5.55% rate. Read the fine print on the new Flagstar account and it has to be NEW money from another source. Messaged Flagstar to add my daughter as joint owner and they sent me a form which I have to download, fill out, have notarized, then MAIL it back to them for consideration. Pointed out that my daughter was ALREADY joint owner of the MBD account but they didn't care. I'm NOT going to go that route, this bank is definitely going down and this is their last gasp for air to breathe. STAY AWAY FROM THEM!
fdic
  |     |   250 posts since 2022
badnarc
Call and ask them to connect you to the virtual bank. Or I can try to find the direct number for you later today. Those guys are very nice, he did everything for me over the phone, including beneficiaries, etc. All I had to do was do a docusign, thats it. He even followed up to make sure that the right interest was credited as I had the same concern as you about "new money". He confirmed they are not enforcing it. I pray this bank doesnt go under as so far I am happy with their CS. I have his email and whenever I have something, I just email him and he calls me back the same day. When the MBD rate changed, he even opened a new additional account for me so that I get a few more weeks of the rate guarantee.
badnarc
  |     |   72 posts since 2023
fdic
THANKS for your info, would appreciate the phone number and email address of the employee. I've been researching Flagstar this morning and everything I see is BAD. Points towards a failing bank so will NEVER go over the FDIC limit. Poppy is my main bank now and I can't find anything bad about them, but no one seems to know much about their status today.

The financial institution, product, and APY (Annual Percentage Yield) data displayed on this website is gathered from various sources and may not reflect all of the offers available in your region. Although we strive to provide the most accurate data possible, we cannot guarantee its accuracy. The content displayed is for general information purposes only; always verify account details and availability with the financial institution before opening an account. Contact [email protected] to report inaccurate info or to request offers be included in this website. We are not affiliated with the financial institutions included in this website.