Time to scratch All-In off your list.
They've had quite a few rate drops recently, with the latest one sending any CD over 1.5yrs down to the 3s.
Last week 36, 48, 60mo CDs were all still 4.07, but not anymore.
Now it's:
36m: 3.87 / 48m: 3.87 / 60m: 3.87 / 24m: 3.97
(100k+ 0.05 higher)
Unfortunately long-term rates are dropping everywhere with the current political/economic situation. Prime Alliance Bank also used to have good longer-term CD rates, but their rates have plunged as well: 48m: 3.75 / 60m: 3.75
There are places with better rates but All-In and Prime Alliance were nice for longer CDs because of their good EWP.