Five Star Bank

Overview / Commentary
55 North Main Street
Warsaw, NY 14569

Five Star Bank is headquartered in WARSAW and is the 21st largest bank in the state of New York. It is also the 244th largest bank in the nation. It was established in 1881 and as of December of 2023, it had grown to 567 employees at 49 locations. Five Star Bank's money market rates are 11X the national average, and it has a B+ health rating.

Reviews (1)

A great NY banking institution-Five Star Bank

A few years back another local chain of banks I was with transferred hands. At first I was leery with a bank change that was out of my control, as has happened in the past, but Five Star was a seemless transition. I received my new information (bank cards/checks along with a welcome package) about a month before the transition to my new bank to ease the tension and frustration of having my hands tied during the change. Once everything was set up and rolling with Five Star, I can honestly say the past few years I've been with them has been overall a great experience. I get my non Five Star ATM withdrawl feels waived monthly just for having a direct deposit set up to my account. Their online banking platform has steadily improved for being a local bank, their app is easy to use, up to date, and very functional. I enjoy the ability like many other large retailers have now, to be able to take aphoto of my check and deposit it to my account straight from the app in the comfort of my own home.

Once I was the victim of fraud as my credit card information was taken and was being used to purchase large items online, it took ONE purchase in a different state of this magnitude for Five Star to hold my card transactions, call me immediately and discuss what happened. Although this was a scary moment, and very frustrating, Five Star sent out a new card right away and in two days I was back to my normal banking. Again, Five Star has been absolutely wonderful since the transition and continued into my normal every day banking. I would reccomend them to anyone looking for a local place to bank with in NY state.


Health Grade Components

FDIC Certificate #659
Year Established1881
Primary RegulatorFED
Profit Margin
Return on Assets - YTD0.88%
Return on Equity - YTD11.79%
Annual Interest Income$287.7MM
Assets and Liabilities
AssetsQ4 2023vs Q4 2022$6.12B$5.76B
LoansQ4 2023vs Q4 2022$4.41B$4.01B
DepositsQ4 2023vs Q4 2022$5.23B$4.96B
Equity CapitalQ4 2023vs Q4 2022$485MM$428.7MM
Loan Loss AllowanceQ4 2023vs Q4 2022$51.1MM$45.4MM
Unbacked Noncurrent LoansQ4 2023vs Q4 2022$26.2MM$9.6MM
Real Estate OwnedQ4 2023vs Q4 2022$142K$19K
Report an Issue

Always verify rates and promotions with the bank or credit union. We are not Five Star Bank; we are a rate comparison website and cannot provide official rates or promotions.

* The APY shown varies based on the deposit amount. Expand the listing to see APYs for other deposit amounts.

Five Star Bank Savings Account Rates

0.05%--Health Savings Account
0.05%--Club Account
0.04%--Statement Savings
0.04%--Business Savings

Five Star Bank Money Market Rates

5.00%*$100k*-High Yield Money Market - New Money
OTHER TIERS: 4.75% $10k - $100k
0.20%*$2.5k*-Business Money Market
OTHER TIERS: 0.15% Up to $2.5k
0.10%--Premier Money Market
0.05%--Money Market

Five Star Bank Checking Account Rates

0.10%--NOW Business Checking
0.07%*$25k*-Premier Checking
OTHER TIERS: 0.05% Up to $25k

Five Star Bank CD Rates

5.00%$500$250k7 Month CD Special
5.00%$500$250k11 Month CD Special
5.00%$500$250kBusiness 7 Month CD Special
5.00%$500$250kBusiness 11 Month CD Special
0.50%$500$250k48 Month Premier CD
0.50%$500$250k60 Month Premier CD
0.50%$500$250kBusiness 48 Month Premier CD
0.50%$500$250kBusiness 60 Month Premier CD
0.45%$500$250k36 Month Premier CD
0.45%$500$250kBusiness 36 Month Premier CD
0.45%$500$250k32 Month Premier CD
0.45%$500$250kBusiness 32 Month Premier CD
0.40%$500$250k48 Month CD
0.40%$500$250k60 Month CD
0.40%$500$250k24 Month Premier CD
0.40%$500$250k30 Month Premier CD
0.40%$500$250kBusiness 24 Month Premier CD
0.40%$500$250kBusiness 30 Month Premier CD
0.40%$500$250kBusiness 48 Month CD
0.40%$500$250kBusiness 60 Month CD
0.35%$500$250k36 Month CD
0.35%$500$250k18 Month Premier CD
0.35%$500$250kBusiness 18 Month Premier CD
0.35%$500$250kBusiness 36 Month CD
0.35%$500$250k32 Month CD
0.35%$500$250kBusiness 32 Month CD
0.30%$500$250k24 Month CD
0.30%$500$250k30 Month CD
0.30%$500$250k12 Month Premier CD
0.30%$500$250k15 Month Premier CD
0.30%$500$250kBusiness 12 Month Premier CD
0.30%$500$250kBusiness 15 Month Premier CD
0.30%$500$250kBusiness 24 Month CD
0.30%$500$250kBusiness 30 Month CD
0.25%$500$250k18 Month CD
0.25%$500$250kBusiness 18 Month CD
0.20%$500$250k12 Month CD
0.20%$500$250k15 Month CD
0.20%$500$250k3 Month Premier CD
0.20%$500$250k6 Month Premier CD
0.20%$500$250k9 Month Premier CD
0.20%$500$250kBusiness 3 Month Premier CD
0.20%$500$250kBusiness 6 Month Premier CD
0.20%$500$250kBusiness 9 Month Premier CD
0.20%$500$250kBusiness 12 Month CD
0.20%$500$250kBusiness 15 Month CD
0.10%$500$250k3 Month CD
0.10%$500$250k6 Month CD
0.10%$500$250k9 Month CD
0.10%$500$250kBusiness 3 Month CD
0.10%$500$250kBusiness 6 Month CD
0.10%$500$250kBusiness 9 Month CD

Five Star Bank IRA Rates

5.00%$500$250k7 Month IRA Special
5.00%$500$250k11 Month IRA Special
5.00%$500$250kBusiness 7 Month IRA Special
5.00%$500$250kBusiness 11 Month IRA Special
0.50%$500$250k48 Month Premier IRA
0.50%$500$250k60 Month Premier IRA
0.45%$500$250k36 Month Premier IRA
0.45%$500$250k32 Month Premier IRA
0.40%$500$250k24 Month Premier IRA
0.40%$500$250k30 Month Premier IRA
0.40%$500$250k48 Month IRA
0.40%$500$250k60 Month IRA
0.35%$500$250k18 Month Premier IRA
0.35%$500$250k36 Month IRA
0.35%$500$250k32 Month IRA
0.30%$500$250k12 Month Premier IRA
0.30%$500$250k15 Month Premier IRA
0.30%$500$250k24 Month IRA
0.30%$500$250k30 Month IRA
0.25%$500$250k18 Month IRA
0.25%*$25k*$250k18 Month Variable Premier IRA
OTHER TIERS: 0.10% $500 - $2.5k | 0.15% $2.5k - $10k | 0.20% $10k - $25k
0.20%$500$250k3 Month Premier IRA
0.20%$500$250k6 Month Premier IRA
0.20%$500$250k9 Month Premier IRA
0.20%$500$250k12 Month IRA
0.20%$500$250k15 Month IRA
0.20%*$25k*$250k18 Month Variable IRA
OTHER TIERS: 0.05% $500 - $2.5k | 0.10% $2.5k - $10k | 0.15% $10k - $25k
0.10%$500$250k3 Month IRA
0.10%$500$250k6 Month IRA
0.10%$500$250k9 Month IRA


The financial institution, product, and APY (Annual Percentage Yield) data displayed on this website is gathered from various sources and may not reflect all of the offers available in your region. Although we strive to provide the most accurate data possible, we cannot guarantee its accuracy. The content displayed is for general information purposes only; always verify account details and availability with the financial institution before opening an account. Contact [email protected] to report inaccurate info or to request offers be included in this website. We are not affiliated with the financial institutions included in this website.