Transfers To NASA FCU Through Shared Branch

marcal
  |     |   52 posts since 2011

Has anyone had problems making a deposit to NASA through a shared branch today? Have you been able to make a transfer to any other shared branch? I'm wondering where the problem is? I haven't been able to make a deposit.



Answers
marcal
  |     |   52 posts since 2011
Called NASA FCU and found out that new member can't use shared branch for 30 days.
Duck
  |     |   111 posts since 2010
Interesting I wonder if they're trying to stem some of the memberships into their CU just for the CD's they are running or if that is written anywhere in their membership. Do you know if they just added it or institute something new on their end marcal because I never had an account at NASA before last Saturday and went Monday to another CU I have never stepped foot in before because the CU I belong to Lone Star had stopped being a shared branch.
marcal
  |     |   52 posts since 2011
I opened my membership and cd at a NASA branch since I was in the area. Wanted to open another one and thought I could use a shared branch, but no luck. Also clarified opening a cd on Sept.29 and funding it Oct. 1st., the rate would be whatever it is on Oct.1st maybe not the 3.25%. I will push funds through Alliant on Monday.
me1004
  |     |   1,379 posts since 2010
Marcal, are you aware that Monday is Oct. 1? You don't know what the rate will be on Monday.

Also, related to what you are saying, the CSR tells me if you open the CD on Saturday, Sept. 29, and fund it that day, because it is a Saturday, the funding will not be credited until the following Monday, Oct. 1, and you will get the Oct.1 rate.

However, if you open the CD the day before, on Friday, Oct. 28, or an earlier weekday, then if you fund it on Saturday, Sept. 29, it will be funded on the 29th and so get this good rate. The key is what day you open the CD, not what day you fund it, so they say. I guess the CD would not be opened on a Saturday technically, even if you do it then.
marcal
  |     |   52 posts since 2011
I’m pushing the money Sept.17. I was hoping to open an acct at the end of the month and fund it on Oct 1 and have the rate be 3.25, but it doesn’t work that way.
me1004
  |     |   1,379 posts since 2010
I just spoke with Nasa, and confirmed what Marcal said -- that the wait for new members before they can use as shared branch is 30 days.

I did not pursue the question further, such as can there be a one-time waiver to open this CD. I opened my membership last March, and they told me because of that, I have no delay, can use it. I should have remembered the other comment here, by Sylvia, about possibly still needing to get approval anyway, so I will ask that when I open the CD this Wednesday.

And by opening on Wednesday, Sept. 19, the CD's 15 months will start on Wednesday so it will mature on Dec. 19, 2019 -- a week before Christmas instead of in the mess of Dec. 29 right up against the weekend between Christmas and New Years. That is, that 10-days for funding provided for a flexible CD maturity date. I'm picking mind as Dec. 19 rather than Dec. 29. I will have until Sept. 29 to fund it, and will do so via shared branch on that Saturday.
me1004
  |     |   1,379 posts since 2010
Today is Wednesday, Sept. 19. I just opened my Nasa 15-month CD, took less than a minute on the phone. Some info:

I did it on the phone rather than online, and the agent confirmed my suspicions, it will be immediate if done on the phone, but can take a while for processing -- maybe days -- if done online, and so that could make a difference to your start date and maturity date. I specifically wanted today as the start date so it would mature as much in advance of Christmas 2019 as possible, 6 days before that. If I waited to open it until I fund it on the 29th, it would have matured Dec. 29, 2019 during Christmas week up against a weekend -- terrible timing!

I will be funding it on Saturday, Sept. 29, via a shared branch near me that has Saturday hours. Nasa also has Saturday hours and will fund it that day.

I have been a Nasa member since March, so I am beyond the 30-day waiting period before a new member can use a shared branch. But I asked about the other question Sylvia mentions, that sometimes you need permission to use the shared branch for a transaction anyway. I was told no need for permission.

Also, today the CSR insisted that once you open the CD, the rate is locked in as long as you fund it within the 10 days. In fact, I already see it in my online account, and it says the rate is 3.20% (that makes for 3.25% APY). I will find it 10 days from now, the 29th. The promo is currently expected to continue to be offered through the 30th, but they do have a line saying it can be changed at any time. But now that mine is opened, the CSR says even if changed, I will still get the 3.25% APY. So THAT CSR said. (I note again, online it says it must be funded no later than the 30th, so I do not expect that rate guarantee will carry past the 30th, unless they chose to continue the promo next month.)
Sylvia
  |     |   389 posts since 2012
Was co-op system down or did branch tell you they were unable to accept your deposit specifically? If it's the latter, subject has been discussed extensively in comments on blog post about latest deal, https://www.depositaccounts.com/banks/nasa-federal-credit-union/offers/. If you're a new member, there could be a waiting period for use of shared branch with NASA. Not a new member? You may need to request approval, as I did. In any event, call them.
Duck
  |     |   111 posts since 2010
In response to Sylvia this is news to me I'm going to read those I just never heard of a waiting period before. I opened Nasa Saturday night online had online access immediately and made my deposit through Prestige on Monday but that was after finding out about Lone star not being a member of shared branch anymore and then intouch not allowing shared banking on Mondays
Sylvia
  |     |   389 posts since 2012
Duck, news to me, too. NASA appears to be tightening access to shared branches due to concern about fraud.
Duck
  |     |   111 posts since 2010
It really didn't matter to me but think there is something to that because they did put a 9day hold on all the funds from the deposits(personal checks) that I made at shared branch. When I called CS @NASA to make sure everything was right she had told me of the hold I just told em whatever as long as it's earning interest if they feel they need to they can put a hold on it for the full term.
me1004
  |     |   1,379 posts since 2010
Hold times for new accounts can be somewhat longer than normal hold times. That generally is for the first 30 days. That is anywhere, not just Nasa.

But other than that, I don't believe shared branch deposits can have any more hold that if you walked into the branch you are depositing to and made the deposit.

But the wait to use a shared branch for Nasa is something I need to look into. I am planning to open a CD there this week and fund it Sept. 29. But I did open my Nasa account many months back, just have never used it, so maybe it won't affect me.
Duck
  |     |   111 posts since 2010
After finding out the CU in Grenville stopped being a shared branch(LoneStar) I had to head to McKinney I had no problem making deposits at Prestige CU in McKinney TX very friendly. I have noticed a few shared are now stating no teller transactions, atm only, limited hours or only on certain days here in Texas In touch CU is one that has services for shared only on certain days
Duck
  |     |   111 posts since 2010
This was fund NASA also
ozempic
  |     |   2 posts since 2018
sorry newbie here but what is a shared branch? I want to get in in the 15 month CD special but is it too late now because seems to be some kind of hold-up between when you apply for it and when you can actually make the deposit? How do you make the deposit anyway? I thought you only need to provide them with your routing and account number from your bank (I plan to fund this from my BBT saving account). And what if the interest drops before you make the deposit? Can you change your mind and just leave an empty account or are you committed to deposit the amount that you signed up for? Many thanks!
me1004
  |     |   1,379 posts since 2010
If you are not already a member of Nasa FCU, it is too late to join and use the shared branch system, they make new members wait 30 days before using it, and at the moment, they are requiring the deposit for that CD to be made no later than Sept. 30. You would have to join and then fund the CD a different way. (This is the only credit union I have come across that has a waiting period to use the shared branch system.)

The shared branch system is an arrangement in which most credit unions allow you to use another credit union to make transactions directly with your account at your credit union. So, you can deposit at a shared branch immediately into your account at a different credit union somewhere else. Not all credit unions are part of the shared branch system, but most are. Other than the deposit, you can withdraw as well (anything over $500 will have to be taken by check, and there is a $5 fort he check), or do other transactions. The transaction is posted to your account immediately, faster event hat same-day Fed funds wire, and free (your credit union pay a small fee to the other for the transaction,less that $1.).

I opened that CD at Nasa yesterday -- and as such, my 15 months is now ticking, although I have not funded the CD yet. They told me once you open the CD, the rate is locked in as long as you fund it within 10 days. I will do so on the tenth day, Sept. 29. (Of course, that 10 days apparently cannot go past Sept. 30, in other words, 10 days or Sept. 30, whichever comes first -- unless they specifically assure you otherwise.) Since I have been a member since last March, I will be able to use the shared branch system to make that deposit.

I didn't ask if you could initiate an ACH with Nasa to pull the money from another bank or credit union, you will have to ask, you probably can. Or, you could mail in a check, if there is no Nasa branch near you, or maybe push from another bank or credit union.
Sylvia
  |     |   389 posts since 2012
NASA's ACH limits are very low, $10K daily, when initiated from within CU. Your best bet there is to get NASA account verified with outside bank that has higher limits, so money can be pushed in.

From reports on the blog post, NASA seems not to be applying the shared-branch waiting period rule consistently. Some new members said they had no problems making deposits. Others told of waiting period were given different durations, 60 and 90 days, not 30. I suggest calling once your membership app is accepted.
me1004
  |     |   1,379 posts since 2010
I learned long ago to doubt anything any CSR says, call back, double check, triple check. So, great point Sylvia to recommend the poster call and see what they can do.

Another point, some banks or credit unions will not only limit the amount that you can ACH out but also how much can be pushed in. I have had at least one bank account that limited how much could be pushed in. They would reject any push that was over that omit. So, ask about that too.
ozempic
  |     |   2 posts since 2018
thank you both for your helpful replies. I was able to open the cd and funded it. It looks like everything is set. Question: is the calculator on this website correct? If I deposit 250K, I will have $10K in interest by the end? That is better than buying a $250K house and rent it out at least for the first 15 months!


The financial institution, product, and APY (Annual Percentage Yield) data displayed on this website is gathered from various sources and may not reflect all of the offers available in your region. Although we strive to provide the most accurate data possible, we cannot guarantee its accuracy. The content displayed is for general information purposes only; always verify account details and availability with the financial institution before opening an account. Contact [email protected] to report inaccurate info or to request offers be included in this website. We are not affiliated with the financial institutions included in this website.