Credit Hit For Closing An Authorized User Card. Should I?

racecar
  |     |   616 posts since 2014

Need some advice if you have the time to take a look...

Even though I never wanted it, many many years ago a family member thought they were doing me a favor and made me an "authorized user" on their department store credit card. The other person is the primary account holder, but I am an "authorized user" with my own card on their account -- and that account shows up on my credit score.

The primary account holder is a person who's good about paying their bills ontime and in full each month, so I just kept things as is and never used it. But then another family member asked the primary account holder for the account # and info, and has used it to get items (delivered) for themselves. Unlike the primary account holder though, this other person doesn't care or even notify the primary account holder when they buy something, so the primary owner always has to notice the bill, pay it, then work out getting payment from the other person.

The problem is, the card is on my credit report, just as if it was my own account. It can help my credit score if handled properly, but can hurt it if there are missed payments. Up to now, there have been no missed payments because of the primary account holder's diligence, but he's elderly, has some medical issues, and I'm trying to decide which would be best.

-Balance is currently paid off ($0)

-While *I* never use the card, it does get occasional use a few times a year, both from the main account holder and this other family member. That could help improve my credit score, as I have no revolving accounts or loans and just a couple credit cards I pay off in full each month.

-The card's available credit is about 7-8% of my total available credit.

-I would rately, if ever, use the card (sometimes a bit of an extra discount but I rarely shop at that store and unless it was a huge purchase would just use MC/Visa).

Should I:

Have my credit score lowered for a few years by closing me from the account? Or keep things as they are, (possibly) getting a mild benefit from others using the card, but chancing what will happen if the primary owner isn't able to see charges rung up by this 3rd family member.

Because there are family dynamics, it's not something where the primary account holder will refuse the other person (and that person already has the card info anyway).

Googling seemed to indicate that the credit hit would be the same for an "authorized user" as for a primary user, but I've never cancelled a credit card before (I have Visa/MCs of my own that can be counted on one hand, and that's it) so I don't know how bad the hit will be if I decide to do it.

How much of a hit does one take when closing a credit card that's used a few times a year?

If I did cancel it, would it help to ask one of my own cards to increase my credit limit by the amount of the card I just cancelled, or not make a difference?

Are the benfits of keeping it open worth the risk of the primary account holder missing purhcases from the 3rd person and having a missing payment pop up on my credit score because of them?



Answers
Kaight
  |     |   1,192 posts since 2011
racecar

I cannot tell you what to do, that is something you must decide on your own.  All I can do is to tell you what I would do were I in your situation:

I would get out from beneath that arrangement absolutely ASAP. I would resign from that alternate user status so fast your head would spin and I would not look back. And I would never, ever, allow myself to be placed in that position again. Period.
Ltssharon
  |     |   471 posts since 2020
100 percent agree
txFish1
  |     |   476 posts since 2023
About 10 years ago I got a Fidelity Rewards Visa and had all but stopped using my BOA credit card so I cancelled it. The hit I took on my credit score was minimal and within no time it was back to where it was before I cancelled the card. I have always had a very good credit score and it has always been important to me to keep it that way so yes for me it would be worth it to close that card and get it out of my name.
racecar
  |     |   616 posts since 2014
Thanks everyone, for your answers.
I did call the places where I have MC/Visa cards and they'll be happy to let me apply to raise my credit limits with them (to make up the available/utilized credit difference), but doing so will require a hard pull, as they consider it like a new application. But regardless if I do that or not, I'm going to go ahead and get myself taken off that store credit card. Don't want to get dinged for other people's actions.

Wow, I can't even remember the last time I requested credit for "real" (not just for them to run my score to open up a savings acct).
Rickny
  |     |   1,296 posts since 2017
When we got pre approved for a mortgage a couple of years ago my credit score went down 5 points from 825 to 820. When I get new credit cards the drop is a couple of points. As mentioned before, any score over 760 is considered good.
  My opinion is things change and I would anticipate the worst scenario if someone has problems paying off debt.
  PD  That's some drop in your credit score for paying a large tax bill but your score after that is still good. I have a mortgage and taxes are paid out of escrow.  My property taxes are over 17k but the taxes are split by schools in June and town, county and agencies in January so the payments are split.


The financial institution, product, and APY (Annual Percentage Yield) data displayed on this website is gathered from various sources and may not reflect all of the offers available in your region. Although we strive to provide the most accurate data possible, we cannot guarantee its accuracy. The content displayed is for general information purposes only; always verify account details and availability with the financial institution before opening an account. Contact [email protected] to report inaccurate info or to request offers be included in this website. We are not affiliated with the financial institutions included in this website.