NASA FCU Will Not Allow You To Take Out Amounts Larger Than $5000 Per Day At A Shared Branch

HollyHolly
  |     |   89 posts since 2015

This is new and was not announced to members. Previously, this was not the case. I had a CD mature this week. I tried to move the proceeds from NASA to another credit union and was told by the teller at the shared branch where I went to perform the transaction that NASA would only permit $5000 to be moved. I called NASA and this was confirmed. The woman I spoke with at NASA said it was due to fraud. I then asked her if in the future I arranged it in advance in writing if it would be possible to move a large amount from a matured CD to another credit union on a specific date at a shared branch, rather than having to get a check or paying for a wire transfer. She was uncertain and suggested I send a secure message through my NASA online acct re this.




Choice
  |     |   937 posts since 2020
Let us summarize...the CU has fraud deterrents in place for $5K or under but not for transactions $5K+...amazing! Amazing b/c they admitted it! ACH ok?
me1004
  |     |   1,381 posts since 2010
There is something very wrong with that. The piont of a shared branch is that it is no different than their own branch. The shared branch checks ID the same as Nasa would.

I had a CD at on CU in the past where I wanted to withdraw all cash and move it to another CU, using a shared branch. I recall the shraed branch was requried to contact my CU and fax the withdrawal paperwork over. It took a few minutes, but then the transaction went through, for a large sum. Supposedly my CU requried that extra step only for legitimately large sums (not $5,000!).

I even avoided taking a check for a payment of $5 from the shared branch, I pointed out I don't need the check or the cash, just transfer the cash to the new CuU and they did.

Point is, if Nasa if afraid a fraud, they can require that extra step, and they can check the faxed signature and ID. That's all they could do at their own branch. There is no excuse to just flat out ban a withdrawal of more then $5,000a day. It presents you from getting your money when you need it! Nasa takes accounts from all over the country,k how does it expect all theose people to go into a Nasa brnach!?

I will say, for transferring from one CU to another at a shared branch, it is always going to be easier to write a check from the first CU and use the shared branch merely to depsit that check to the other CU. I always want to open a checking account where I put a CD so I can do just that, but I don't want expense for checks or whatever, I try to get at least a few starter checks, I don't need a full order. This is how I plan to handle it in about two weeks when I close my CD at Nasa and move it to another CU.
FHB
  |     |   8 posts since 2013
As my CD's at NASA matured I transferred the proceeds to my checking account there intending to ACH funds to my local checking account. It took a few days to set up, however, I can transfer only a maximum of $10,000 per day per NASA's rules.
Sylvia
  |     |   389 posts since 2012
I've been told by a credit union rep that shared branching is recognized to be the #1 source of fraud for CUs. NASA, being especially fraud conscious, is pretty strict about use of shared branching. For example, if you've not used it in over a year, don't be surprised if your transaction is rejected. This happened to me when I attempted to make a deposit a few years ago. I had to get re-authorized for shared branching by NASA.

I try to do everything by ACH, initiated from external institution. When my CDs mature at NASA, I have them transfer proceeds to savings, then pull out funds using outside FI. When I want to open a CD, I deposit funds to savings, again, initiating ACH from outside FI, thus avoiding NASA's many restrictions.
me1004
  |     |   1,381 posts since 2010
If you don't have a transaction in your account for over a year, your account goes dormant, and that blocks transactions until you contact the CU to reactivate it. You have to keep it active by making sure to have a transaction. And they generally will then start charging you a monthly fee.
alan1
  |     |   880 posts since 2015
I believe me1004 may have misunderstood Sylvia's very useful post. Sylvia, writing about shared branching, added: "For example, if you've not used it in over a year, don't be surprised if your transaction is rejected." The word "it" refers to shared branching.

I believe Sylvia's comment has zero to do with accounts going dormant or transactions being blocked until something is "reactivated".

Apologies to Sylvia and/or me1004 if I'm the one who is failing to understand something.
Sylvia
  |     |   389 posts since 2012
Thanks for the clarification, alan1. You’re absolutely right: it’s activity on shared branching for NASA account, not on NASA account generally. I first wrote about that experience here, https://www.depositaccounts.com/banks/nasa-federal-credit-union/offers/#p20699 (comment #85, 9/5/18; updates on #107, 9/6, & #129, 9/7). Others chimed in with additional info.
me1004
  |     |   1,381 posts since 2010
I just spoke with Nasa FCU (I have a CD maturing next weeek), and because of the info here, I asked about use of shared branching.

The CSR said that you are limited to withdrawals of $750 cash and $5,000 for a cashiers check. All the shared branches I have used have had low cash limits, rest by check at a cost of $5. So, you would face a low cash limit regardless, its the amount of the check that is the problem.

I asked why they are imposing that. She said it was started with the pandemic, That's all. I don't know what the pandemic has to do with shared branching, but that's the word. I suppose every CSR will give different info, as usual.

Deposits via a shared branch are unlmited.

Re the reauthorization if you haven't used shared branching in a few years, the CSR I spoke with said she had never heard of that, but that they do have some restrictions on a case by case basis. I coud not get an idea from her of what might bring about those restrictions. She assured me there are no restrictions on my account, including none on shared branching other than the withdrawal limits on everyone. I opened a 15-month CD in December 2019, and that woud be the last time I used shared branching, 1.25 years ago. The only other transaction I've had was on Feb. 1 of 2020, a little over a year ago, looks like I did it to avoid any issue of inactivity.

I don't know what this means, other than different info from different CSRs, as usual. But there you have it. As Sylvia says, it's not a bad idea to check. As for my CD, it will close to my checking account and I will write a check from there -- so no issue of trying to withdraw it at a shared branch.


The financial institution, product, and APY (Annual Percentage Yield) data displayed on this website is gathered from various sources and may not reflect all of the offers available in your region. Although we strive to provide the most accurate data possible, we cannot guarantee its accuracy. The content displayed is for general information purposes only; always verify account details and availability with the financial institution before opening an account. Contact [email protected] to report inaccurate info or to request offers be included in this website. We are not affiliated with the financial institutions included in this website.