NFCU: Example Of A (Perhaps) Unintended Public Service

Kaight
  |     |   1,192 posts since 2011

Does intent really matter all that much? When good is accomplished, do we condemn the beneficence merely because it was not the purveyor's goal?

I think not. Case in point:

This website's NFCU health rating remains at "C". Some would argue this misrepresentation should by now have been put right. I disagree. That "C" rating has the benefit of possibly steering newcomers away from NFCU and toward other financial institutions where they will do far better investing their money. Today's NFCU is a major disappointment, though admittedly not from a health standpoint. But NFCU's CD offerings do not rank among the best. So if that "C" rating carries a "look elsewhere" message, it is for the best in my view.

On a personal note, I have legacy CD's at NFCU at this moment. But I'm a "short timer" there. Very soon, though not soon enough, my CD's will mature. And when they do, my money will be "gone with the wind" where NFCU is concerned unless something changes pronto.

NFCU at one time offered some very attractive CD deals. That was then. This is now. Things have changed.




CDMD
  |     |   142 posts since 2022
If a C rating is incorrect it should be changed. Justifying this incorrect notation as a means to scare others away as a rationalization is just not right. The rates and each individuals decisions are stand alone and is best made with fully transparent information.  The decision to pick another rate and institution is easily available by the rate tables.  Bad information cannot be selective.  This site would lose its credibility if it were justified as you described
choice1
  |     |   371 posts since 2023
“Look Elsewhere”…Your logic should drive everyone to something other than a certain CD reporting service, etc. that knowingly misrepresents the financial condition of largest CU in USA. The info should not be posted!
choice1
  |     |   371 posts since 2023
Let me try again…why is DA tarnishing the reputation of a major FI by knowingly posting incorrect info? Hello!  And the victim is?  Got it…some think that offering so-called lower rates justifies false info!  
111
  |     |   672 posts since 2019
Frankly, to some degree that "major FI" (Navy FCU) has already "self-tarnished" its own reputation - by offering nothing but seriously sub-par rates to its own heretofore loyal, long-term depositors.

"Seriously sub-par" not just in my own opinion (which is eminently ignorable), but in terms of a comparison with Navy FCU's rates over the last several rate cycles, relative to other FIs at the time!
racecar
  |     |   628 posts since 2014
I have moved on from NFCU as well. Their specials used to be good enough to put up with their slow, backwards way of doing things. Not anymore. I do have a 7yr long term 4.2% (or thereabouts) IRA CD at just the bare minimum in case rates really plummet over the next 7 years... I'm not expecting them to, but it was a cheap insurance policy, as Navy usually lets you add on to IRA CDs each year. But other than that, the rest of my IRA and normal funds are now all elsewhere. As the largest CU in the country, I'm sure they don't care about me -- and I feel the same way about them.
cooper9
  |     |   3 posts since 2024
I think the thing to remember here is not everyone cares about Interest rates, Heck if this was the case Chase, Bank of America etc would not exist. I have friends who are perfectly fine making 0.01 on their savings and it works for them... While I use Amex, Ally etc for higher rates- some people put more value on having a real branch, real people if need be and decent services. While I do not claim Navy is the best- over all they are fine. There flagship checking is not bad at .40% interest with no fees and free checks if you use them. Plus the flagship card is pretty good for the low fee.
They are the number one cu in the country by miles and even larger then many banks- they will go nowhere...I use four of the top ten CU's and they all have great points and head scratchers.


The financial institution, product, and APY (Annual Percentage Yield) data displayed on this website is gathered from various sources and may not reflect all of the offers available in your region. Although we strive to provide the most accurate data possible, we cannot guarantee its accuracy. The content displayed is for general information purposes only; always verify account details and availability with the financial institution before opening an account. Contact [email protected] to report inaccurate info or to request offers be included in this website. We are not affiliated with the financial institutions included in this website.