New York Community Bank Reviews

Average Rating:
Based on 11 review

5 star:
4 star:
3 star:
2 star:
1 star:

Atrocious Customer Service

Posted by: |

I went into the branch at 265 N. Broadway in Hicksville to make what I thought would have been a routine deposit. There were no tellers at any of the stations. I sat on a chair and waited for a while. Eventually a teller showed up and thanked me for waiting. That was a fairly minor, though unacceptable, inconvenience and all was forgiven.
However, they infuriated me by refusing to accept a legitimate insurance company's check that was made out to me and my wife. We had both endorsed the check and I was depositing it into my wife's account because we do not have a joint account.
They have a sign that says "double endorsed checks will not be accepted unless approved".
I was personally at the bank, I had proper identification, and I was depositing the check into my wife's account. Why my check could not be approved is beyond me. That is HORRIBLE customer service. The lady who I almost lost my temper with was probably a manager or senior person but she has absolutely no inkling of good customer relations and should be FIRED.

The Worst Bank You Will Ever Find.

Posted by: |

Freezing accounts for no reason. Can't get a straight answer. The employees must be incompetent and indifferent to be hired. My money is coming out of there. Stay far away.

Why I Would Never Change Banks

I have been a customer at my local bank for twenty three years and will never change banks. The main reason I would never leave is because of the customer service I have been receiving all these years. When I walk in to the bank, everyone knows me and my family as well. They ask about how my son is doing all the time as well as my parents. They know me personally which is something I can't say about any other financial institution in this area. I have a credit card, three CD's, multiple checking accounts and a savings account all with this bank. When my CD's mature, I return to this bank to renew them and I trust their advice. I believe that this bank has many long time customers like me because I see how friendly they are with others when I come to the bank. Last year, I had someone that had stolen a lot of money from my checking account. I went straight to the bank and they took care of the situation. They returned my money very quickly and I never had any problems after that. The funny thing is that I am considering purchasing a house in a couple of years and I plan on going to them to inquire about a mortgage loan. I often think that even if I move further away, I would still continue to come to this bank despite the longer drive.


Posted by: |

I executed two ACH $50,000 transfers out of my account with NYCB and received emails confirming both transfers.

The next day 7/17/17, i received an email and a voice mail stating that the first of two ACH withdrawals would be cancelled if I did not call the bank by 4PM EST (even though it is now DT). So I called the person that called and emailed me and she was not available.

I spoke to 3 people and spend 90 minutes on the phone and finally was reassured that my TWO transfers would be executed. I told the person I spoke with, that I would be closing my account after these problems. That was at about 4 PM Eastern time, 7/17/17.

I logged into my account 30 minutes ago and discovered that my second $50,000 transfer that was confirmed by their employee was cancelled, AFTER I HAD RECEIVED EMAIL CONFIRMATION THAT THE TRANSFER WOULD BE DONE.

Anyone who deposits their money with this bank, after my warning has only themselves to blame for the problems that will certainly result.

Avoid this bank.

Ridiculous Treatment Of Captive Customers

Posted by: |

Perhaps deposit accounts are treated better, but head the warning before doing business with a company who treats its customers like this.

The website roll-out, customer service, and company employee attitude that I have dealt with are absurd. My mortgage was sold to this institution so I am stuck -- can't believe how painful it is to work with this company. I have in the past and currently pay mortgages to 7 different companies. Few hiccups do occur in accessing tax records, getting billpay right, escrow maintenance, forgotten passwords, etc,etc... all easily resolved at other places. With MYNYCB, it is a struggle to simple log in and pay. I have considered incurring refinance fees just to move my loan somewhere else. The good news is that waiting 90 minutes in line at the Department of Motor Vehicles next to screaming toddlers just to transfer a title seems more reasonable now that I have banking with NYCB to compare it to.

Ohio Savings - NOT!!

Posted by: |

Sadly I agree with the other two customers. I have been with Ohio Savings for many years. They were bought by New York Community Bank and the service has been terrible. I don't need to be redundant, but I have had numerous problems in terms of freezing my account when traveling, not being made aware of processing times, non-consumer-friendly ATM'a and others.

I will definitely be changing banks ASAP!

Checking Account Issues

Posted by: |

I have had a checking account with Ohio Savings for over 25 years.  I have never had an issue until the last 2 years.  First issue:  about 2 years ago, a check for $400 deposited to my account bounced.  They removed the $400, but I noticed that my "available balance" was missing an additional $400.  When I inquired, I was informed that "that is just a policy".  When I asked why they were holding $400 of MY OWN money (after charging me a $36 fee), they could not give me an answer.  They did ask "did you need the funds?"  By unusual circumstance, the missing $400 luckily did not cause any of my checks to bounce.  When I asked to speak to a supervisor, one was not available and I was told I would be contacted, but I never heard from anyone. 

8 days ago, I deposited a personal check for $8000.  A paycheck also was auto-deposited, and a few items were debited, leaving me an average of $8800.  5 business days later I transferred $4500 to another account.  No problem.  At 6 business days, I transferred $1000 to a credit card.  The next day, I charged $970 on my debit card to the car dealer.  The next day, my card was denied, and I looked up my account, and it said "available balance - $0". I inquire.  The person says, "I'm thinking what happened is sometimes a business will request double the amount to be held in the account.  It looks like maybe that happened with the $970."  I said, "What, I've never heard of that".  the response was, "Oh, yes, sometimes vendors will do that.  It should come off in a couple days".  The next day, I look at my account, and the $1000 has been returned and $36 charged.  I inquire.  I'm then told that deposits over $5000 take 7 days to clear, and it will be available at midnight tonight. Under that it's only 3 days.  I say, "o.k., let's count.  7 days would have been yesterday.  Why did the $970 clear, but the $1000 did not?  And how am I to know of this difference in policy?"  I was told I should have been able to tell by the amount available.  But the amount available was different each time, sometimes $3000 of that 8 was available.  And why was I told that story about the double holding when I was asking yesterday?  And why was I able to transfer $4500 of that money right away?

I told them I was extremely upset over this.  I asked why was my $500 overdraft not enacted?  I was told because it wasn't really an overdraft (but apparently STILL warranted a RETURN FEE).  I asked if it could be refunded as a courtesy, and was told no, since THE SAME THING HAD HAPPENED ONCE BEFORE AND I WAS AFFORDED THAT COURTESY BEFORE.  Yes, this was the second incident of them witholding a payment transfer and then charging me for it.  So I'm done.  I will be looking for another bank. 

The financial institution, product, and APY (Annual Percentage Yield) data displayed on this website is gathered from various sources and may not reflect all of the offers available in your region. Although we strive to provide the most accurate data possible, we cannot guarantee its accuracy. The content displayed is for general information purposes only; always verify account details and availability with the financial institution before opening an account. Contact [email protected] to report inaccurate info or to request offers be included in this website. We are not affiliated with the financial institutions included in this website.