Dedicated to Deposits: Deals, Data, and Discussion

Internet Banks and Rate Chasing - Is It Worth It?


I just reported on the new internet bank, SFGI Direct which is offering a no-minimum savings account with a competitive rate of 2.25% APY (see account review). A question that many people may ask is:
Is it worthwhile to open yet another online savings account? Isn't it just a matter of time that the rate will fall and be comparable to the average online savings account?

Some new internet banks offer an intro rate guarantee so you'll know the rate won't plummet in the next month (or the next day in some past cases) after you open the account (see list). If you're concerned for the long-term, even these intro rates may not mean much if the rates still plummet after the intro period is over.

How long will competitive rates last?

You may be able to get some idea of how long a bank will be able to maintain high rates by the size of the bank. A small bank that brings in 500 new customers who deposit on average $100,000 will generate $50 million in new deposits. For a small bank with total deposits of $100 million, $50 million of new deposits can easily be overwhelming. It'll be unlikely that they'll be able to make use of all these deposits through loans (especially in today's environment). For a larger bank with $10 billion in deposits, an additional $50 million in deposits only adds 0.50% to their total deposits, and it's more likely that they won't be overwhelmed and be forced to cut rates or limit availability.

There have been examples of new small internet banks keeping their rates competitive after their intro period. One example is CNB Bank Direct. They began in September 2008 with a 4.00% APY guaranteed for 6 months. The 6-month guarantee ended in October, and they still have a competitive rate of 2.00% APY as of 7/25/09 (see account review). Also CNB Bank Direct's parent, Citizens National Bank, isn't a large bank. As of March 31, 2009, it only has $565 million in assets and $418 million in deposits. In 9 months from 6/30/08 to 3/31/09, their deposits have grown from $350 million to $418 million. I would assume much of this increase is due to the online bank. This example shows that nationwide internet banks with competitive rates still don't bring in huge amounts of deposits relative to the banks' more traditional deposit sources.

An internet bank that's part of a large bank doesn't guarantee rates will stay competitive. One example is OnBank which is part of M&T Bank Corporation, one of the 20 largest independent bank holding companies in the U.S. When OnBank was launched in April 2008, it was offering a very competitive online savings account. The competitive rates lasted for much of 2008, but in the last several months, the interest rate has been a pathetic 0.50%.

So it's not easy to judge how well the rates will hold up for the long term.

Ease of moving your money

If an online bank doesn't make it easy to transfer money to other banks, there's more risk in opening an account. It's the risk of leaving your money in the account after rates have fallen because it's too much hassle moving the money to a higher interest rate account. This can be the case if the bank doesn't provide an ACH bank-to-bank transfer service.

Even if a bank does have an ACH transfer service, it can still be problematic if they make it hard to link to another account. Some banks require you to mail in a voided check if you want to create a link. In addition, some limit the number of links you can have to as little as one. Another issue can be the size of the allowed transfes. Some banks have transfer limits as low as $2,000.

Even if a bank doesn't provide an ACH transfer service, most will allow you to withdraw or deposit funds using an ACH transfer service from another bank. However, there are a few which do not allow this.

Opening too many accounts

Even when the bank makes it easy to move your money, there are issues regarding opening new accounts. Banks sometimes do hard credit pulls in the application which can temporarily ding your credit score. Also, if the bank uses ChexSystem in the application, that inquiry goes on your ChexSystem record. Some banks will reject your application if you had too many recent ChexSystem inquiries. So you may miss some future hot deal if you've opened too many accounts.

There's also a cost in time. Opening new accounts take time. Monitoring your accounts also take time. There are websites like Mint.com and Yodlee that can make it easy to track multiple accounts. But there are potential downsides to these services. If you have tips on reducing the time and effort on this, please leave a comment.

Cost of rate chasing

There's also a direct cost with rate chasing. When you initiate electronic transfers, there is often a time in the transfer process when that money isn't earning any interest. For example, you initiate a transfer at a bank on Thursday. The money may be debited from that account on Friday. It may not be credited to your destination account until Wednesday of the following week. So you may miss out on 5 days of interest.

MyMoneyBlog has a useful calculator to help you evaluate the cost of transfers.

Another issue with rate chasing is the risk of fees. Some online banks have monthly fees if your balance falls too low or if your account lacks activity after a certain amount of time. So if you transfer most of the money to a new higher interest rate account, you may be hit with fees from that old account if you don't close it or if you are not careful.

That's one benefit of having accounts without minimum balance requirements. However, don't assume requirements will remain unchanged. There have been cases in which online banks have added minimum balance requirements or raised the minimum balance requirements. Also, don't assume no-minimum literally means no minimum. I recommend keeping at least $1 in a no-minimum account. Many times banks will close an account when the balance falls below $1 even when they advertise it as a no-minimum savings account.

So are you still rate chasing? What tips do you have?

To compare high-yield savings accounts, please refer to my weekly rate summary.

Alternatives to internet savings accounts

Reward checking is an alternative to the internet savings account. But reward checking isn't immune to falling rates. To compare rates of reward checking accounts and to learn more about them, refer to my High Yield Checking website.

Help is Appreciated!

If you've enjoyed this post, please help me out on the Tipd.com website (no money, just exposure) See Tip'd's FAQ to learn how to vote for this article.


Related Posts

Comments
10 Comments.
Comment #1 by Marc Schoenfeld (anonymous) posted on
Marc Schoenfeld
Great post. I don't think you got carried away. This is just the train of thinking that should be going on and if people aren't already considering these factors in their decisions already, it's good to get the word out.

I think another thing to consider is the potential for bad service. If you currently have a bank that is performing well and not giving you hassles, you always risk that the next bank will not be so good and end up not worth the extra headaches for small amount of increased interest. But if the rate increase by moving is large, the risk of this is worth taking. Reviews can help decide this, but you never know what your experience will be.

1
Comment #2 by Anonymous posted on
Anonymous
Banking Guy, you have a very good blog that is very useful. I find it somewhat amusing when I see you write that a bank is “offering a very competitive rate of 2.25% APY.” Yes, it’s true in today’s environment 2.25% is good. That’s the sad part. I’m looking for the 5.00% and 6.00 % interest rate days to return.

At this point I have stop rate chasing. But I must stress that this is because I’m a “little fish” in the financial stream. For me, $10,000 is a lot of money, and as one can see, moving such small amount for a fraction of a percent doesn’t make much sense.

I do miss the credit card offers that paid you to open an account. The University of Iowa was my favorite. They paid new customers $250.00 just to open an account! So within 15 minutes I opened one for myself and one for my wife. Five hundred dollars for fifteen minutes of typing was great. Let’s do it again! :-)

Banking Guy, keep up the good work. And as a note to the other reader’s who enjoy this site, let’s help out Banking Guy by using his links such as Amazon if we are going to buy something from there anyway. Banking Guy deserves to get a very small commission on our purchase. It doesn't cost us anything extra and it’s a way to show him that we appreciate all of the research that he does for us.

-1
Comment #3 by Rick (anonymous) posted on
Rick
A friend suggested using PayPal to transfer funds between banks. It takes about 7 days round trip from your home bank to PayPal and then onto the Internet bank. When funds arrive in your account at PayPal you receive an email. There is no charge and PayPal will call you within a few minutes of making the transfer to verify it is really you making the transfer.

1
Comment #4 by Matthew (anonymous) posted on
Matthew
Rick, I would not recommend PayPal as an intermediary between bank accounts. First, the 5-7 days is longer than even the slowest bank's ACH service. Second, funds held in PayPal (even for a few days) are not FDIC-insured. Third, PayPal has the potential to lock your account at anytime if they suspect fraud. This has not happened to me personally, but there are many accounts of this that you can find online. Most importantly, why would you do this? There are a number of banks you can use as an intermediary between banks with slow or nonexistent ACH transfer capabilities, which are far superior to PayPal in all of these aspects. You may even earn some interest in making the transfer!

1
Comment #5 by Anonymous posted on
Anonymous
Yes, I just register on Tipd.com and put my vote on this informative blog. It is very easy. It only takes me a minute to do it. Thanks again, Banking Guy. I follow your blog several times a day.

1
Comment #6 by James (anonymous) posted on
James
I believe it is worth it, but I use reward checking. I just recently opened an account that promises 4.44% apy out of an account that is paying 3.01%. For me, at least 1% point above is worth the small hassle to switch money, but I do investigate the bank and call them regularly to ask questions before opening an account.

1
Comment #7 by Anonymous posted on
Anonymous
I've just opened a reward checking account, too.
This rate environment in one way has been good in that it has led me to clean house somewhat. I have, or rather had, an increasing number of bank accounts because of either rate chasing , or bonus chasing so have been consolidating and closing, or at least emptying most of them and using local B&M, reward checking and Alliant. Not worth it to chase now and greatly simplifies things. Most all of Alliant funds now in reward checking but keeping a bit in there so have a secondary access to immediate funds if there is a problem with the reward checking.

1
Comment #8 by Anonymous posted on
Anonymous
Banking Guy,
Great post as usual.
SFGI pays interest once each cycle. I think it's important to make sure that withdrawals should be made immediately after the interest is paid, otherwise a month's interest is lost on the funds withdrawn. This is also important when closing an account.

1
Comment #9 by Anonymous posted on
Anonymous
Bankdeal is great.

I have chased rates since the early 80's and 15% CD rates. Got completely out of the market in Dec of 1999 and found Bankdeals when it was mentioned in either Money Magazine or Kiplingers a few years ago. Have given the site address to many friends. Afterwards I thought if everyone knows about the site and opens an account before I do will I still get one. So far I have been able to.
Great job on this site. You have helped many people. Just opened up a CD at NASA today.

1
Comment #10 by RateBrain (anonymous) posted on
RateBrain
I agree that rate chasing ends up being a waste of time usually.

I use a combination of BankDeals and RateBrain.com -- BankDeals for the in depth and interesting posts, and RateBrain for the latest and greatest rates.

1